MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Dr Benjamin Hardy13 November 2021

A High Achievers' Guide To Happiness - Dr Benjamin Hardy - #397

2Frameworks
11Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster01:30

Happiness is a burden if you think you have to go get it

Hardy argues happiness is not outside you and not something to pursue or chase. If you feel you must accomplish something to become happy, you have made happiness a burden and are trying to fill an internal emptiness with external achievement.

  • Chasing external happiness signals an internal hole that achievement cannot fill
  • You set goals because you are already happy, not to become happy
  • Ambition and being in the gain can coexist — the goal just is not the source of happiness

it's an endless chase to nowhere because the the hole is inside of you it's not outside of you

Benjamin Hardy · 02:30
#happiness#fulfillment#goals#mindset

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take17:00

Seek growth, not status

A lesson Hardy takes from Dan Sullivan: chase growth rather than status. Seeking status offers no guarantee of growth and may even stall it once achieved, whereas genuinely seeking growth tends to accumulate status as a byproduct.

  • Reaching a status target can plummet your growth afterward
  • Status-seeking does not reliably produce growth
  • Growth-seeking usually accumulates status you were not chasing
  • You can have all the status yet not actually be growing as a person

you should seek growth not status because if you're seeking status you might not actually grow or... it might plummet your growth

Benjamin Hardy · 17:00
#status#growth#ambition#success
Hot Take46:30

Your past is a fiction you make up

Hardy claims your past is a fiction just as your future is — you can recall events accurately, but the emotions, energy, and meaning are your own creation. Citing Marcus Aurelius, he argues life is but what we deem it, so you can keep returning to the same experience and extracting more from it.

  • You can recall events, but you author their meaning and emotion
  • You can revisit one experience for years and get more gold each time
  • Experiences either happen to you or you happen to them
  • Marcus Aurelius: 'life itself is but what we deem it'

your past is a fiction by the way just as your future's a fiction... you're the one making up what your past means

Benjamin Hardy · 46:30
#meaning#narrative#stoicism#reframing

Explainer· 4

Explainer00:30

Why most high achievers are chronically unhappy

High achievers run a hedonic treadmill, measuring themselves against ever-receding ideals like a horizon in the desert. No matter how far they have come, they devalue their current position because they are always focused on where they wish they were.

  • The gap is measuring against your ideals, which keep moving with you
  • You may be living beyond your former self's dreams yet still feel behind
  • It is like being your own worst enemy who never acknowledges a win
  • 'What are you going to do next?' constantly moves the goalposts

it doesn't matter how successful you are compared to your former self if you're always measuring yourself against the horizon in front of you you're…

Benjamin Hardy · 01:00
#happiness#high-achievers#hedonic-treadmill#psychology
Explainer10:00

Wanting vs needing: harmonious vs obsessive passion

Hardy distinguishes healthy wanting from unhealthy needing. Wanting requires no justification and comes from intrinsic motivation; needing means you feel incomplete without the thing. In psychology this maps to harmonious versus obsessive passion — and if something owns you, you are its slave.

  • You never need to justify a want — you want it because you want it
  • Obsessive passion makes the goal own you and drive the ship
  • Harmonious passion is intrinsic and healthier — commitment without attachment
  • NFL example Trevor Lawrence: fully committed to football but does not need it

if you feel like you're attached to something then it owns you you don't own it and that's really what obsessive passion is

Benjamin Hardy · 11:30
#motivation#passion#intrinsic-motivation#psychology
Explainer11:30

Where the gap mentality comes from

Kids are more intrinsically motivated; the gap is learned. Public education trains you to measure against external, authority-given reference points and against other people, and culture later supplies the yardsticks — social media likes, money — so we never build an internal reference system.

  • Schools grade you against external standards and against peers
  • Culture and upbringing supply externally-driven reference points
  • We rarely develop an internal system of measuring against ourselves
  • The fix is deciding what reference points you actually care about

we never develop an internally referencing system where we just start measuring ourselves against ourselves and deciding what we want

Benjamin Hardy · 13:00
#education#culture#comparison#psychology
Explainer13:30

Freedom from vs freedom to

Hardy describes two psychological levels of freedom. Freedom from removes poverty, toxic environments, or ignorance; its purpose is to deliver freedom to — the courage to pursue what you genuinely want because you want it, which is self-actualization.

  • Freedom from: escaping poverty, toxicity, ignorance
  • Freedom to: choosing and pursuing what you want for its own sake
  • Chasing what you want takes more courage than pleasing others
  • This is what psychology calls self-actualization

it takes a lot of courage to actually chase what you want because you want it

Benjamin Hardy · 14:00
#freedom#self-actualization#autonomy#psychology

Story· 1

Story53:30

What's the point of success if you're miserable?

Chris and Hardy question success celebrated at any cost, citing strongman Eddie Hall nearly wrecking his family to win. Hardy relays Derek Sivers' Richard Branson thought experiment: if Branson's true dream was to be a painter, his business empire could not count as success — being true to what you genuinely want matters more than external measures.

  • Society applauds success even when it annihilates someone's life
  • You cannot take a holistic view of another person's happiness from outside
  • Sivers: if Branson secretly wanted to be a painter, he was not a success
  • External achievement is empty if it is not what you truly want

it doesn't matter what you accomplished if it wasn't what you genuinely wanted to do or believed in for yourself

Benjamin Hardy · 59:30
#success#meaning#happiness#values

Tool· 1

Tool49:30

Deliberate rumination and proactive gratitude for trauma

To transform a hard experience you must approach it, not avoid it. Deliberate rumination — sitting down to frame what happened, what you learned, and what you can be grateful for — differs from intrusive rumination, where a random trigger drags you into the dumps. Gratitude can be applied to anything, not only good outcomes.

  • Intrusive rumination: avoidance plus random triggering into low mood
  • Deliberate rumination: intentionally framing and mining the experience
  • Approach the experience via a journal, therapist, or friend
  • Apply proactive gratitude even to painful events like a parent's addiction

the only way you can move forward and for it to cease being a trauma is once you actually have framed it as a gain

Benjamin Hardy · 47:30
#trauma#rumination#gratitude#resilience

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway03:30

Confidence is the byproduct of past performance

Hardy argues you cannot have confidence in future performance — only in what you have already done. Because the only thing you can actually measure is your past, being in the gain (measuring backward) is what builds the confidence that fuels your next move.

  • You can only measure what you have done, not future performance
  • Confidence comes from evidence of past accomplishment
  • That confidence then initiates and enlarges what you attempt next
  • Being in the gap starves you of this confidence

you can't have confidence in future performance you can only have confidence in what you've done

Benjamin Hardy · 03:30
#confidence#self-belief#performance#psychology
Takeaway60:30

Why they wrote The Gap and the Gain before 10x

Hardy explains the deliberate ordering of the Dan Sullivan book series. There is no point helping someone 10x their income or audience if they stay in the gap the whole way, so the happiness book had to come before the growth book.

  • The Gap and the Gain is aimed at helping high achievers be happy along the way
  • 10x is Easier Than 2x follows, but only makes sense once you are in the gain
  • Growth without the gain just scales the same unhappiness

there's no reason to help people go 10x if they're going to stay in the gap the whole way

Benjamin Hardy · 60:30
#books#growth#happiness#sequence