MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Connor Beaton16 January 2025

A Man’s Guide To Feeling Your Feelings - Connor Beaton - #890

2Frameworks
15Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take05:30

Run an emotional 'shit test' early when dating

Chris proposes deliberately over-indexing on emotional openness early in dating — sharing feelings or a psychology article — to see whether a partner can hold space for it. Better to find out someone can't handle your emotions now than five or ten years into a marriage.

  • Test early whether a partner can sit with something outside the typically expected
  • If they can't hold the space, you learn it before years of investment
  • The relationship is meant to be your safest harbor for your darkest moments
  • If a partner can't handle you opening up, that is their problem, not yours

over indexing on that as soon as possible once you've got past the very very early stages just allows you to see okay is this…

Chris Williamson · 06:30
#dating#vulnerability#relationships#compatibility

Explainer· 6

Explainer00:00

Why men got a bad reputation with emotions

Beaton argues men do not feel less than women — they feel very deeply — but several generations were handed suppression as their only emotional tool. Culture created a vacuum where men were never taught what to do with intense emotions, cutting them off from important data.

  • Men feel intensely, which is why letting emotions loose can be loud and big
  • A few generations were told their best tool was suppression and repression
  • The bumbling, emotionally-out-of-touch sitcom dad became the default role model
  • Society says it wants men to open up but no one knows how to handle it when they do

it's not that men don't feel I think it's that men feel very deeply and we've in some cultures created a vacuum of being able…

Connor Beaton · 01:00

no one has any idea how to deal with a man that's going through a very intense set of emotions

Chris Williamson · 03:00
#masculinity#emotional-suppression#conditioning#role-models
Explainer09:00

Men soften and women harden as they age

Beaton describes a pattern where men generally become less harsh and aggressive as they age while women often become harder. He attributes much of it to shifting hormone balances — declining testosterone in men and relatively rising testosterone in post-menopausal women.

  • Men tend to soften psychologically and become less angry as they get older
  • Women often move in the opposite direction and become harder emotionally
  • Declining testosterone in men and hormonal shifts post-menopause drive much of it
  • Couples describe partners feeling like completely different people through menopause

men generally as they get older will soften psychologically... and women go in the opposite direction generally speaking women become harder as they get older…

Connor Beaton · 09:00
#aging#hormones#menopause#relationships
Explainer20:00

The rider and the elephant: rational vs intuitive mind

Beaton uses the psychology metaphor of a rider (the rational mind) atop an elephant (the intuitive, emotional, physical body). Western culture over-indexes the rider, but the elephant carries vastly more information — more signal travels from body to brain than the reverse.

  • The rider is the rational mind; the elephant is the intuitive and physical body
  • Culture honors the faithful servant (reason) and forgets the sacred gift (intuition)
  • More information flows from body to brain than brain to body, per van der Kolk
  • There is safety in the rational mind because it avoids understanding the body

the rational mind is a faithful servant and the intuitive mind is a sacred gift and we've created a culture that honors the servant and…

Connor Beaton · 20:00
#psychology#intuition#mental-models#body-awareness
Explainer41:00

Grief is praise — and it must be witnessed to be processed

Beaton frames grief as the natural way love honors what it misses, and says it attaches to any transition, not just death — even to achievement. His key claim: grief that is not witnessed cannot be processed, which is why people stay stuck unable to move on.

  • Grief is tied to transition, from career changes to lost teams
  • Grief can arrive at moments of achievement — Beaton's own 'escape velocity' grief
  • Grief that is not witnessed is not processed
  • Deferred grief pushed down the road turns into a slow depression

grief that's not witnessed is not processed

Connor Beaton · 45:00

grief is praise because it is the natural way that love honors what it misses

Connor Beaton · 41:00
#grief#transition#witnessing#depression
Explainer47:30

Depression needs pressing out, movement, and asking for help

Beaton distinguishes depression's 'anvil on the chest' from explosive emotions. Beyond expression and being witnessed, depression requires actively pressing outward — the gym, breathwork — and asking for help without offloading full responsibility onto a savior.

  • Depression closes in like a weighted blanket you can't get out from under
  • It requires pressing out: working out ruthlessly and breathwork help most
  • Breathwork and psychedelics can quiet the default mode network to access feeling
  • Ask for help without falling into a victim mindset that demands a savior

part of depression is asking for help asking for support without falling into the trap of obfuscating the responsibility to the other person

Connor Beaton · 48:30
#depression#breathwork#exercise#asking-for-help
Explainer56:30

Until a man faces powerlessness, he abuses power

Drawing on Richard Rohr, Beaton argues that a man who has never experienced a journey of powerlessness will always abuse power. Feeling overwhelming emotions is a modern initiation — deliberately entering a state you cannot dominate to learn something essential about yourself.

  • Rohr: until a man experiences powerlessness he will always abuse power
  • Traditional initiation thrust boys into experiences they could not conquer
  • Overwhelming emotions are an initiatory experience you feel powerless against
  • The formula is to actively choose powerlessness for a period — not to wallow in it

until a man experiences a journey of powerlessness he will always abuse power

Connor Beaton · 56:30
#initiation#power#mythology#maturity

Story· 3

Story10:30

Choosing transparency through grief and new fatherhood

Beaton shares losing his mother to cancer and having his daughter born shortly after. His growth was in answering his wife's check-ins honestly — saying 'today sucks' and naming both the joy and the brutal grief — instead of his old method of glazing over it with another scotch.

  • His mother got sober after a terminal cancer diagnosis before she passed
  • His wife's habit of checking in gave him room to be honest
  • He held joy at his daughter's birth and grief for his mother simultaneously
  • The old default was numbing with substances instead of admitting how he felt

my willingness to be transparent about this this is joyful on the one hand... but also be very real and transparent about there's part of…

Connor Beaton · 11:30
#grief#fatherhood#vulnerability#personal-story
Story21:30

'Man up' and 'suck it up' came from wartime dissociation

Beaton traces phrases like 'man up' and 'suck it up' to World War II, where survival required men to dissociate from their bodies. He argues generations of men were placed in horrendous situations that demanded emotional shutdown, embedding suppression as social conditioning.

  • 'Man up' reportedly meant getting into the tank; 'suck it up' meant swallowing your own vomit to keep fighting
  • Killing an enemy requires disconnecting from the emotional body
  • Wartime dissociation was rational survival, not weakness
  • This historical conditioning bled into everyday male emotional suppression

there's all of these adages where men have been put into horrendous situations that require them for survival purposes to deploy disassociation

Connor Beaton · 22:00
#conditioning#history#dissociation#masculinity
Story51:30

The Tiger Woods swing rebuild: getting worse to get great

Chris uses Tiger Woods rebuilding his entire swing from the ground up — deliberately making himself worse under full public expectation — as an analogy for emotional work. You must abandon effective old habits and tolerate an undefined stretch of feeling incompetent before reaching the next level.

  • Woods was good but had to rebuild his swing to become great
  • He made himself purposefully worse before he could level up
  • Emotional work means getting worse for an undetermined, unrewarded period
  • Beaton warns finance-minded men who refuse any slide back will sabotage instead

he had to get rid of all of the habits that he had brought in and make himself purposefully worse before he was then able…

Chris Williamson · 52:00
#skill-acquisition#analogy#growth#discomfort

Q&A· 1

Q&A16:30

Four signs you have a problem with your emotions

Beaton lists indicators that you are cut off from your feelings: high reactivity and a quick temper, emotions dragging on your ability to act, over-indexing on the rational mind with no felt sense, and 'emotional constipation' — difficulty even acknowledging you feel something.

  • High reactivity: reacting from defensiveness, judgment, or hostility to small stimuli
  • Emotions becoming a drag that stops you doing what you know you need to do
  • A total disconnection from bodily sensation — a 'nervous system decapitation'
  • Emotional constipation: being unable to express or even acknowledge a feeling

emotional constipation you know where where somebody really has a hard time expressing experiencing or even acknowledging that they are feeling something

Connor Beaton · 19:00

it's like a nervous system decapitation

Chris Williamson · 19:00
#self-diagnosis#reactivity#emotional-awareness#temper

Takeaway· 4

Takeaway07:30

Attachment is built by surviving hard times together

Beaton relays his therapist friend Dewey Freeman's saying that the foundation of attachment is going through a hard time and coming out the other side. Monogamy guarantees hardship, and how a couple weathers it determines the relationship's quality and longevity.

  • The foundation of relationship is going through hardship and emerging together
  • Long-term monogamy makes some form of hardship inevitable
  • People underestimate how much they will change over 5, 10, 15 years
  • Willingness to be transparent about what you're going through is decisive

the foundation of attachment is going through a hard time and coming out the other side

Connor Beaton · 08:00
#attachment#relationships#monogamy#resilience
Takeaway28:30

Anger is the alarm system for your boundaries

Beaton reframes anger as necessary rather than a problem: it is an alarm signaling that a boundary has been crossed. Men disconnected from their anger tend to have poor boundaries and get walked over because they have no real sense of 'no'.

  • Anger is necessary for setting boundaries
  • If you treat anger as a problem you likely have piss-poor boundaries
  • Anger is an alarm that something was crossed or overstepped
  • Create a pause, then communicate the boundary — not from the anger itself

anger is necessary for setting boundaries... your anger is an alarm system sometimes that a boundary has been crossed

Connor Beaton · 29:00
#anger#boundaries#emotional-intelligence#assertiveness
Takeaway70:00

Do this work in a men's group, not solo monk mode

Beaton advocates men's groups over the lone-wolf 'monk mode' instinct. Progress accelerates among men speaking the same language and witnessing each other, and the volatility of getting annoyed by another member is itself the point — a chance to confront and express what you'd normally suppress.

  • The tendency to isolate and 'work on yourself' alone is a trap
  • A community of men witnessing each other accelerates progress exponentially
  • Getting irritated by a group member is the material to work through
  • Coming back a perfect person after 12 months of monk mode is a fantasy

our tendency is to do it solo right we want to loan wolf all of this and what I found is that most men... you…

Connor Beaton · 71:00
#community#mens-groups#accountability#isolation
Takeaway81:30

Start by naming what you're avoiding — the drive to be fully known

Beaton's single takeaway: start by acknowledging what you are avoiding emotionally to someone you trust, echoing Jung that confession is the first step of any therapeutic process. He argues the deepest human demand is to be fully known, and honest expression is the only path to that intimacy.

  • Start by naming what you're avoiding: your anger, depression, or anxiety
  • Jung: confession is the first step of any therapeutic process
  • Set it up properly with a trusted person rather than dumping ad hoc
  • The greatest demand within any human being is to be fully known

just start by acknowledging what you are avoiding emotionally

Connor Beaton · 82:00

the greatest demand within any human being is to be fully known

Connor Beaton · 83:00
#confession#intimacy#first-step#being-known