MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Caleb Jones20 June 2019

How Does A Non-Monogamous Marriage Work? - Caleb Jones - #082

4Frameworks
8Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster04:00

Alcohol Is the Only Drug Where Not Using Is Seen as a Problem

Caleb Jones highlights a societal double standard: while people don’t question abstinence from heroin or cocaine, choosing not to drink alcohol often invites suspicion or assumptions about addiction. He shares his personal choice to remain sober despite working in nightlife.

  • Society assumes a problem if someone doesn’t drink alcohol, unlike other substances.
  • Caleb has never been drunk and chooses sobriety for personal freedom and clarity.
  • He worked as a club promoter for over a decade without drinking, proving it’s possible in high-pressure environments.

Alcohol is the only drug where if you don't do it, people assume you have a problem.

Caleb Jones · 04:00
#sobriety#alcohol#social-norms
Myth Buster09:00

Why People Assume Sobriety Means Alcoholism

Caleb challenges the assumption that not drinking implies past addiction, explaining that sobriety can simply be a lifestyle choice. He shares how people often assume he’s religious or recovering, when he’s neither.

  • Society equates not drinking with having a problem, not personal preference.
  • Caleb is agnostic and never drank, despite working in nightlife.
  • He rejects labels like 'alcoholic' or 'religious' to describe his sobriety.

People assume that I'm Christian or Mormon or something like that. 'Oh, you must be really religious.' No. I'm agnostic.

Caleb Jones · 09:00
#sobriety#social-perception#lifestyle-choice

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take28:00

Traditional Monogamy Doesn’t Work Long-Term

Caleb argues that lifelong sexual monogamy is fundamentally incompatible with human nature, citing high divorce and infidelity rates as evidence. He advocates for honest, structured non-monogamy as a more sustainable alternative.

  • 76%+ divorce and 77% infidelity rates show monogamy doesn’t work for most.
  • Humans are pair-bonding creatures but not sexually monogamous by nature.
  • Denying natural desires leads to cheating, resentment, or divorce.

We are pair-bonding creatures. We are not monogamous creatures.

Caleb Jones · 28:30
#monogamy#divorce#relationship-models

Explainer· 1

Explainer00:00

Why Non-Monogamy Doesn't Mean No Pair Bonding

Caleb Jones explains that non-monogamy and pair bonding are not mutually exclusive. He emphasizes that one can be deeply committed to a partner emotionally while still having sexual relationships with others, as long as ground rules are established early.

  • Non-monogamy allows sexual freedom while maintaining emotional commitment to one partner.
  • Pair bonding refers to emotional exclusivity, not sexual exclusivity.
  • Ground rules must be discussed before a relationship becomes serious to avoid future conflict.

I am pair bonded. I'm married. I am pair bonded to one woman who I share my life with, who I love.

Caleb Jones · 28:00
#non-monogamy#relationships#emotional-bonding

Q&A· 1

Q&A35:00

Can You Raise Kids in a Non-Monogamous Relationship?

Caleb confirms that raising children in a non-monogamous marriage is possible, provided parents maintain consistency, privacy, and emotional stability. He shares an anecdote about a happily married couple with kids who practiced open marriage discreetly.

  • Children can thrive in non-monogamous families if rules and boundaries are clear.
  • Parents should not parade partners in front of kids or make lifestyle choices public.
  • Discretion protects both children and the relationship from societal judgment.

You can have kids. A lot of people have kids. You just can't parade women around your kids, obviously.

Caleb Jones · 36:00
#parenting#non-monogamy#family

Tool· 1

Tool06:30

How to Handle Social Pressure to Drink

Caleb shares a practical strategy for navigating social situations where drinking is expected: ordering a sweet wine like Riesling to appear compliant while sipping slowly, thus avoiding scrutiny without compromising personal values.

  • Ordering a sweet, light wine like Riesling helps deflect attention.
  • Sipping slowly makes it seem like you're drinking normally while consuming very little.
  • The goal is to maintain comfort in social settings without giving in to pressure.

I get a Riesling, little girly wine, tastes almost like apple juice, and I would take a sip. They go, 'Oh, good, he's drinking. Okay,…

Caleb Jones · 06:30
#social-skills#alcohol#lifestyle-choice

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway55:30

Jealousy Is a Barrier to Long-Term Happiness

Caleb asserts that extreme jealousy is not a sign of strength or love, but a psychological barrier to happiness. He encourages men to work on emotional control and self-awareness to build more sustainable relationships.

  • High jealousy indicates emotional immaturity, not passion.
  • Men should aim to reduce jealousy from a '12' to a '6' or '7' for long-term happiness.
  • Even monogamous men benefit from managing jealousy to avoid relationship suffocation.

If you're that angry and that jealous... there's something wrong with you in terms of your long-term happiness.

Caleb Jones · 56:00
#emotions#jealousy#relationship-advice
Takeaway61:30

The Optimal Relationship Structure for Men

Caleb outlines what he sees as the least bad, most sustainable relationship model: a long-term emotionally exclusive partnership (OLTR) with mutual permission for casual outside sexual relationships, especially after age 35.

  • Emotionally exclusive, sexually open relationships are more sustainable than strict monogamy.
  • Men should not settle down before age 35 to ensure self-awareness and stability.
  • Casual sex on the side (FBs) is acceptable as long as it doesn’t threaten the primary bond.

The least bad scenario is a long-term pair bonded wife or girlfriend... and you are allowed to get sex on the side within ground rules.

Caleb Jones · 62:00
#relationship-structure#men#long-term-happiness