Abby Davisson18 March 2023

How To Make Life's Biggest Decisions - Abby Davisson - #603

1Frameworks

12Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Strategy5 steps

The Five C's Decision Framework

Make life's biggest money-and-love decisions with both head and heart

Read →

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster30:30

The child-care math most couples get wrong

Couples typically deduct child-care costs from one partner's paycheck and conclude the job isn't worth it. The correct approach adds both paychecks and deducts child care from the joint total, treating both careers as a long-term investment.

Raising a child is estimated at about half a million dollars to age 18
Don't subtract child care from just one person's salary
Add paychecks together, then deduct child care from the joint total
Pausing a career is costly because re-entry is hard

“you add the paychecks together you deduct the child care from The Joint paycheck because it is actually a long-term investment in the careers of…”
Abby Davisson · 31:30

#parenting#careers#money

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take46:30

How to guarantee the worst possible divorce

Asked what would produce the least amicable divorce, the answer is: try to win. Treating divorce as a one-time negotiation where you extract maximum money and refuse to compromise creates the messiest outcomes, especially where children are involved.

Trying to 'win' produces the worst divorces
Extracting maximum money and refusing compromise escalates conflict
Clarify whether an amicable relationship matters more than winning
An amicable split protects children from having to take sides

“if you are trying to not have an amicable divorce really seeing it as a one-time negotiation right where you are more likely to just…”
Abby Davisson · 47:30

#divorce#negotiation#conflict

Explainer· 5

Explainer04:00

Get to the source code of what you actually want

Many of the things we want aren't truly ours; they come from societal norms, past trauma, and paths of least resistance. Clarity requires programming deeper than surface desires to reach what you want to want.

Family, friends and managers all cloud what you care about
Wants often trace to societal norms or past trauma, not you
Reach the 'source code' of your desires
Distinguish what you want from what you want to want

“the things that you want aren't necessarily the things that you want to want they just they come from all over the place”
Chris Williamson · 04:30

#clarity#desire#self-knowledge

Explainer17:00

Front-load the big conversations before you feel ready

Couples avoid hard early conversations for fear of seeming too keen, but front-loading topics like career ambition, children, money, and where to live reveals compatibility and builds closeness. The alternative is discovering misalignment after you're too invested to turn back.

Cover career aspirations, children, money habits, and location
Early vulnerability actually brings couples closer
Waiting until you're deeply invested makes trade-offs painful
Tease out the compromises before promises are made

“make sure that the person that you're with has values and a life plan that aligns with yours sounds kind of obvious but is also…”
Abby Davisson · 22:00

#relationships#compatibility#communication

Explainer23:30

Beat dating-app overwhelm with simultaneous choice

Stanford research by Baba Shiv contrasts sequential choice (endless swiping toward an imagined perfect person) with simultaneous choice (bounding the options and comparing them at once). People who pick from a bounded set they experience simultaneously report more satisfaction.

Sequential choice fuels an eternal quest for someone better one swipe away
Simultaneous choice bounds the options and compares them together
Shiv chose among three suitors met in the same window and married happily
You can fake simultaneous choice by comparing a current candidate to recent ones

“people who identify their best choice from a number of choices that they experience simultaneously have are more satisfied with the outcomes”
Abby Davisson · 24:30

#dating#paradox-of-choice#research

Explainer25:30

Have the prenup conversation even without the document

Prenups are on the rise, but the value is in the discussion, not necessarily the legal paperwork. Going through the same steps, disclosing all debt and being financially transparent, lets couples enter marriage with eyes wide open.

Prenups are rising as people marry later with more assets and debt
The conversation matters more than signing a document
Disclose all debt and be financially transparent
A facilitator like a therapist or financial coach can help

“we don't think it's important to have a prenup necessarily but to go through the same conversations and have the same discussions you would have…”
Abby Davisson · 26:30

#marriage#money#prenup

Explainer53:00

Have elder-care conversations before you need them

Elder care conversations are easier in the abstract than in a crisis. Tread lightly, understand what matters to your parent, and explore options like home health aides and life-plan communities. Blaming the prompt on a book or article can make the topic easier to raise.

These talks are far easier before decisions are imminent
Options range from home health aides to life-plan communities
Long-term care insurance is rare; Medicare/Medicaid cover little
Advance directives, including one for driving, spell out wishes early

“it is easier when you don't need to make those decisions imminently”
Abby Davisson · 59:00

#elder-care#aging#family

Tool· 2

Tool35:30

The weekly 'taking care of business' check-in

To stop one partner constantly nagging the other about household admin, schedule a recurring half-hour check-in. Putting the mundane logistics on the calendar removes the need to bring them up ad hoc and gives them a neutral, agreed setting.

Schedule a weekly slot for household logistics
Once it's on the calendar, no one has to raise issues out of the blue
Tailor the format: drinks, a walk, or a plain kitchen-table sit-down
A neutral setting stops it feeling like one person always nagging

“having a weekly check-in um we call it uh tcob taking care of business where we just have it on the calendar”
Abby Davisson · 36:00

#couples#household#communication

Tool50:30

Prototype a big move instead of visiting for a weekend

Borrowing from design thinking, prototype the life you'd have somewhere rather than the holiday. Rent a place for a month so you experience laundry, groceries, and the unglamorous parts, offsetting the holiday effect that makes any new place feel great.

A fun weekend visit misleads you about daily life
Rent for a month to approximate real living
This is prototyping, borrowed from design thinking
Talk to people who already made the same move

“you're trying to prototype what your life would be if you lived in Austin so you are spending more time there than just a weekend”
Abby Davisson · 51:30

#relocation#design-thinking#decision-making

Takeaway· 3

Takeaway00:00

Why not making a decision is itself a decision

Much of our stress comes from decisions we're avoiding rather than making. Choosing not to act is still a choice with real consequences, so inaction carries a price people wrongly assume is zero.

The reason you're stressed is often unmade decisions
Not deciding is in itself a decision
Inaction has a cost people ignore
Everything you do, including not doing something, is doing something

“the reason you're stressed is because you have decisions to make and you're not making them”
Chris Williamson · 00:00

“you have to consider the price that you pay for inaction because people presume that inaction has no cost”
Chris Williamson · 09:30

#decision-making#stress#inaction

Takeaway07:30

Confidence comes from process, not outcome

For those prone to analysis paralysis, running a decision process provides the confidence that you consulted the right people and turned over the right rocks. Even when outcomes go sideways, you know you couldn't have done better.

The process gives confidence you approached it well
You can't anticipate everything, so judge the approach not the outcome
'You've done your best, Angels couldn't do better'
Readers report feeling more confident after using the process

“you've done your best Angels couldn't do better”
Abby Davisson · 08:30

#analysis-paralysis#confidence#regret

Takeaway39:00

People regret the risks they didn't take

The most common life-decision regret in the research is not taking risks, not making the big move, not trying the thing you always wanted. People don't regret working too little at the office; they regret not spending time with loved ones and not leaping when they could have.

The top regret is not doing, not doing badly
Regret clusters around risks and moves not taken
We over-egg our risk aversion
Making a big life change tends, on average, to make people happier

“people regret not spending time with people they love and not taking risks not going for the big move”
Abby Davisson · 39:30

#regret#risk#psychology