MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Dr Robert Waldinger19 January 2023

Lessons From The World's Longest Study On Happiness - Dr Robert Waldinger - #578

3Frameworks
15Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 3

Myth Buster20:00

Money keeps buying happiness, just less and less

The old idea that happiness plateaus above a set income looks wrong. The emerging consensus is that happiness rises at every income level but with diminishing marginal returns. It still isn't always worth chasing more money if you must sacrifice leisure, friends or family to get it.

  • For poor people, more money reliably raises happiness
  • The consensus now: happiness rises at every income level
  • Gains shrink as income climbs (diminishing marginal returns)
  • What you give up to earn more (leisure, family) can offset the gain

happiness increases at every level of income, but it increases less and less the more money you make

Erik Angner · 21:00
#money#happiness#economics#income
Myth Buster

The myth that you can be happy all the time

The biggest misconception about happiness, Waldinger says, is that doing all the right things means being happy 24/7. Nobody in the study is happy all the time. Social media curation amplifies the illusion, making people feel they're uniquely the only one whose life isn't beautiful, while media and advertisers sell the promise of nonstop happiness to sell products.

  • A happy life does not mean being happy all the time — nobody is
  • Curated social feeds hide the ordinary, hungover, confused moments
  • This makes people feel uniquely defective
  • Advertisers deliberately sell the myth of permanent happiness

nobody's happy all the time. That a happy life does not mean being happy 247.

Robert Waldinger
#happiness#social-media#misconceptions
Myth Buster

You don't need to be an extrovert to get the benefits

Shy and introverted people are not shut out of relationship benefits. Everyone differs in how many people they need, but everyone needs at least one solid connection — someone who has their back — to feel the world is okay. Waldinger endorses the most useful definition of introversion/extroversion: whether you're energised by being around people or by being alone.

  • Introverts can get full relationship benefits with fewer connections
  • Everyone needs at least one solid 'has my back' relationship
  • A large friend circle is optional, not required
  • Best definition: energised by people (extrovert) vs by solitude (introvert)

you need one connection that's really solid to feel like the world is an okay place for you.

Robert Waldinger
#introversion#extroversion#relationships

Explainer· 6

Explainer

Why snapshots lie: the 'born Cuban, die Jewish' problem

Waldinger contrasts longitudinal studies, which follow the same people for decades, with cross-sectional snapshots that compare different age groups at one moment. Snapshots generate false correlations, illustrated by a joke that South Florida's young Cuban Americans and older Jewish Americans make it look like you're 'born Cuban and die Jewish.'

  • Cross-sectional studies compare different people of different ages at one time
  • This can create false impressions of how life progresses
  • Longitudinal design tracks the same individuals over their whole lives
  • It avoids reliance on people reconstructing past memories

When I look at South Florida, I would have to believe that you are born Cuban and you died Jewish.

Robert Waldinger
#methodology#research#statistics
Explainer

How much of happiness is in your control: the 50/10/40 split

Citing psychologist Sonja Lyubomirsky, Waldinger notes roughly 50% of well-being is genetically determined, about 10% comes from current life circumstances, and about 40% is malleable and under our control. The takeaway is that you can meaningfully move the needle on roughly 40% of your happiness.

  • ~50% of well-being is genetically set
  • ~10% comes from current life circumstances
  • ~40% is malleable and under your control
  • Attributed to psychologist Sonja Lyubomirsky

about 50% of our well-being is genetically determined... another 40% is more under our control. It's malleable.

Robert Waldinger
#happiness#genetics#psychology
Explainer

Why relationships protect your body: stress regulation

Waldinger's mechanism for how relationships get 'into the body': we're built to enter fight-or-flight under stress and return to baseline once the threat passes. People without emotion-regulating relationships stay in chronic fight-or-flight, carrying higher circulating stress hormones and chronic inflammation that break down multiple body systems, explaining links to heart disease and arthritis.

  • Relationships act as stress regulators that return the body to baseline
  • Without them people stay in chronic fight-or-flight mode
  • Chronic stress means high stress hormones and inflammation
  • This breaks down multiple body systems at once
  • Talking to a partner can be physically felt as the body calming down

people who can't do that stay in a kind of chronic fight or flight mode... the body has higher levels of chronic inflammation, and that…

Robert Waldinger
#stress#health#inflammation#relationships
Explainer

The stroke speed that maximises oxytocin release

Williamson shares that there's an upper-bound speed — roughly a few centimetres per second — at which stroking someone's arm releases oxytocin, an evolutionary holdover from primate grooming. The same slow speed is what most quickly calms crying babies and toddlers. Move faster and it just becomes annoying rather than soothing.

  • Oxytocin release from touch peaks in a narrow slow-stroke speed window
  • Roughly a few centimetres per second, an inheritance from ape grooming
  • The same speed calms crying babies fastest
  • Faster stroking loses the soothing effect

there is a maximum speed that you can stroke somebody's arm at in order to release the amount of oxytocin.

Chris Williamson
#oxytocin#touch#neuroscience
Explainer

Why achievement and awards don't make you happy

Achievement helps happiness only when the thing itself is personally meaningful — a personal best you're proud of. Achievement pursued as a badge of 'having arrived' — awards, prizes — feels good for maybe a day and then fades. Waldinger cites Nobel laureates who get depressed after winning ('gold medalist syndrome') because they still have to live their ordinary lives.

  • Achievement matters when it's meaningful to you personally
  • Achievement as a status badge never lasts — good for about a day
  • Nobel winners can get depressed after winning
  • 'Gold medalist syndrome': the arrival high evaporates fast

achievement as a way to be a badge of having arrived, that never lasts.

Robert Waldinger
#achievement#status#meaning#happiness
Explainer

Why we seek partners who feel like a painful childhood

Childhood conditions our expectations of relationships and the world, but those expectations aren't destiny. Waldinger, drawing on his psychotherapy practice and Freud, describes people as 'heat-seeking missiles' who gravitate toward what feels familiar — even when familiar means painful. Part of good therapy is helping people see they keep choosing partners who resemble the people who hurt them as children.

  • Childhood teaches us what to expect from people and the world
  • Those expectations can change but aren't automatically overwritten
  • People seek what feels familiar, even if it's painful
  • We often choose partners who echo the hurtful figures from childhood
  • Escaping it means deliberately finding more trustworthy relationships

they're like heat-seeking missiles. They seek out what feels familiar. And sometimes that's painful stuff that feels familiar.

Robert Waldinger
#childhood#attachment#therapy#relationships

Story· 1

Story

Inside the 85-year Harvard Study of Adult Development

Waldinger explains how the longest study of the same people's lives began in 1938 as two unrelated studies — privileged Harvard undergraduates and disadvantaged Boston youth — later merged as contrasting groups. Over 2,000 people, their spouses and children have now been followed, with findings cross-checked against non-Western studies to correct for the sample's 'weird' demographic.

  • Started 1938 as two separate studies that didn't know about each other
  • Merged in the 1970s as privileged vs underprivileged contrast groups
  • Over 2,000 people tracked across generations for 85 years
  • Originally all white American men; now more than half women via spouses and children
  • Findings only published when corroborated by studies of non-Western, non-white groups

It's the longest study that we know of of the same people going through their entire lives. And it started as two studies that didn't…

Robert Waldinger
#longitudinal-study#harvard#methodology#history

Q&A· 1

Q&A

What marriage and children actually do to happiness

On average, people in an intimate partnership (marriage license optional) are somewhat happier and live longer, though the effect size is modest and plenty of married people are unhappy. Children, by contrast, neither raise nor lower happiness on average — having kids is a life choice, not a happiness lever. Friendships can fully substitute for a marriage.

  • Partnered people are on average somewhat happier and live longer
  • The marriage effect is real but statistically modest, not massive
  • Children make people neither happier nor less happy on average
  • Friendships can provide the same support as a marriage

people in an intimate partnership are as a group happier. Can you be happy without an intimate partnership? Absolutely. But you have to beat the…

Robert Waldinger
#marriage#children#relationships#happiness

Takeaway· 4

Takeaway

Loneliness is as toxic as smoking half a pack a day

The study's headline health finding: social isolation and loneliness are as damaging to physical health as smoking half a pack of cigarettes daily or being obese. People who were better connected and more satisfied with their relationships stayed healthier and lived longer — an effect that first emerged in the 1980s and was later confirmed by other studies.

  • Isolation and loneliness rival smoking half a pack a day for health harm
  • Better-connected, more satisfied people lived longer and stayed healthier
  • Effect first appeared in the 1980s and was initially disbelieved
  • Relationship quality genuinely predicts disease risk like heart disease and arthritis

social isolation and loneliness are as toxic to our health as smoking half a pack of cigarettes a day or being obese.

Robert Waldinger
#loneliness#health#longevity
Takeaway

Self-centered people are measurably less happy

The data show that people who were really self-centered and didn't take care of others were less happy, and that antisocial behaviours drive both fewer friendships and less happiness. Waldinger, a psychiatrist, adds an observation that the most egregiously self-centered public figures often appear to have the most troubled, tormented inner lives.

  • Self-centered people who neglect others scored as less happy
  • Antisocial behaviour drives both fewer friends and less happiness
  • Harming others tends to engender less happiness — what goes around comes around
  • The most self-centered people often appear the most inwardly troubled

the people who were really self-centered and the people who did not take care of others were less happy.

Robert Waldinger
#character#selfishness#happiness
Takeaway

It's never too late to find friends or love

Countering people (even those in their 20s) who conclude connection will never happen for them, Waldinger reports that the decades of data show people repeatedly get surprised by their lives. People in their 50s, 60s, 70s and 80s found new friend groups or fell in love for the first time. He shares a friend in his late 60s who just had a child and only now understands what having a family feels like.

  • People conclude too early that connection won't happen for them
  • The data show it's never too late — people are surprised by their lives
  • New friendships and first-time love appear in the 50s through 80s
  • A late-60s friend just started a family and found it beautiful

People find love in their 70s and 80s who they who've never had it before... it's never too late.

Robert Waldinger
#connection#aging#hope#relationships
Takeaway

Waldinger's own simple daily happiness practices

Asked what he personally does, Waldinger lists deliberately simple, 'dull' practices: meditate every day, exercise every day, connect with people every day. He adds that watching trash TV and eating dark chocolate also contribute, keeping the prescription refreshingly unglamorous and doable.

  • Meditate every day
  • Exercise every day
  • Connect with people every day
  • Small pleasures like trash TV and dark chocolate count too

I meditate every day, I exercise every day, I connect with people every day. Those are the three things.

Robert Waldinger
#habits#routine#meditation#happiness