MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Baggage Claim31 October 2022

Modern Cinema Treats Women Like Idiots - Baggage Claim - #546

0Frameworks
8Insights

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster11:30

She-Hulk Isn't Empowering—It's Narcissistic

The guest argues that She-Hulk promotes a narcissistic worldview by portraying the protagonist as flawless and entitled, dismissing heroic efforts as narcissistic while centering her own life. This, she says, teaches young women that their motivations are never to be questioned.

  • She-Hulk calls the Avengers 'narcissists' for risking their lives to save others.
  • Her entire show revolves around dating, fashion, and self-obsession.
  • She dismisses Bruce Banner’s trauma as less valid than her own.
  • This sends a dangerous message: women are perfect, others are beneath scrutiny.

“She says, 'No, it's for narcissists.' And immediately cuts down one of the most successful stories this universe has told.”

guest · 12:00

“Her motivations are never to be questioned because I'm a female. That's a very bad lesson to teach anybody.”

guest · 13:50
#she-hulk#narcissism#feminism#media-criticism

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take31:00

Female Empowerment Shouldn't Mean Acting Like Men

The guest criticizes the trend of equating female strength with masculine traits—like calling Valkyrie 'King' instead of 'Queen'—arguing it devalues traditional femininity and implies being a woman is inferior unless she mimics men.

  • Calling Valkyrie 'King' implies 'king' is superior to 'queen'.
  • This messaging undermines female identity and reinforces male default.
  • True empowerment shouldn't require women to reject femininity.
  • Reducing motherhood to 'womb haver' is dehumanizing.

“Why? Oh, apparently it's better to be king than queen. Right? Isn't that the messaging that they're saying?”

guest · 31:20

“Female empowerment means acting like a man. That's the new way that this is seen.”

host · 32:00
#gender-identity#femininity#cultural-narratives#media-messaging

Explainer· 1

Explainer00:00

Why House of the Dragon Gets Women Right

The guest praises 'House of the Dragon' for portraying women as complex, capable of both power and destruction. Unlike modern superhero films, it shows female characters with flaws, ambitions, and moral ambiguity—making them compelling and realistic.

  • Women in 'House of the Dragon' are not idealized or patronized.
  • They are shown as capable of strategic cruelty and political maneuvering.
  • The show avoids the 'perfect victim' trope common in woke media.
  • It presents a balanced view of feminine strength and darkness.

“Just because you're a woman does not mean you're inherently good. You can be crazy. You can be destructive. And that's what I like about…”

guest · 00:05
#house-of-the-dragon#female-characters#tv-criticism#storytelling

Story· 2

Story04:00

How Thor and Loki Were Reduced to Jokes

The guest recounts how Thor and Loki, once powerful and complex characters, were rewritten into comedic, emasculated versions of themselves—Thor as a clown riding a broom, Loki as a bumbling fool—suggesting the writers were enacting a form of narrative revenge rather than telling compelling stories.

  • Thor was degraded from a god to a joke in 'Love and Thunder'.
  • Loki was portrayed as incompetent, dancing and forgetting missions.
  • Female counterparts (Sylvie, Jane) were used to belittle the male characters.
  • The writing felt like a public humiliation rather than character evolution.

“It was embarrassing to watch him. It was a farce to take a man that is supposed to be this god and make him this…”

guest · 05:20

“It felt as if the writers were exacting some form of revenge on these characters.”

guest · 04:20
Story49:00

Fleabag Shows the Destructive Side of Femininity

The guest praises 'Fleabag' for portraying a self-destructive woman who hides deep guilt. Unlike modern heroines, she is flawed, complex, and capable of causing real harm—making her a rare example of authentic female storytelling.

  • Fleabag sleeps with her best friend’s boyfriend, leading to her suicide.
  • She hides this truth for most of the series, showing moral complexity.
  • The show breaks the fourth wall to reveal inner chaos.
  • It acknowledges women’s capacity for emotional destruction.

“She is a character who's very self-destructive and she does a lot of things including hooking up with men that make her unhappy.”

guest · 49:50
#fleabag#female-antagonist#tv-criticism#emotional-complexity

Q&A· 1

Q&A01:00

What Does 'More Sensitive James Bond' Actually Mean?

The guest discusses the producers' claim that the next James Bond will be more emotionally open, expressing concern that 'sensitivity' could undermine the character's strength rather than enhance him. She values Bond’s traditional masculinity and fears a deconstruction that reduces him to a caricature.

  • Bond’s appeal lies in his mental and physical strength, not emotional fragility.
  • Making Bond more 'sensitive' risks turning him into a weak, unrelatable figure.
  • The guest supports evolving female roles but not at the cost of erasing male archetypes.
  • She praises Vesper Lynd as a strong female character who balanced equality without diminishing Bond.

“I think part of what's very attractive about James Bond is that he is a macho character who's very powerful physically, but also mentally.”

guest · 01:20

“If they go too extreme... where he stops being what makes James Bond so exciting and interesting, I think that would be a really big…”

guest · 02:50
#james-bond#film-culture#gender-roles#character-development

Tool· 1

Tool38:00

America Chavez: A Case of Narcissistic Storytelling

The guest analyzes America Chavez’s arc in 'Doctor Strange 2' as emblematic of a broader cultural trend: the idea that believing in yourself is enough, without struggle or growth. This, she argues, reflects a narcissistic worldview that undermines real development.

  • America Chavez has no character development.
  • The climax hinges on 'just believe in yourself'.
  • This mirrors the self-esteem movement’s flaw: valuing belief over effort.
  • It teaches that struggle and mentorship are unnecessary.

“Zombie Benedict Cumberbatch comes back to say to her, 'I just came here to tell you that you need to believe in yourself.'”

guest · 40:20
#doctor-strange#america-chavez#narcissism#story-criticism

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway20:00

Woke Cinema Fails Because It’s Patronizing

The guest argues that modern cinema patronizes women by portraying them as flawless victims, which is ultimately disempowering. Real strength comes from overcoming struggle, not from being told you’re perfect.

  • Patronizing portrayals make women feel pitied, not empowered.
  • Characters who never face criticism or growth are unrelatable.
  • Audiences reject these stories, as box office results show.
  • True empowerment includes self-doubt, growth, and accountability.

“It's patronizing. As far as I can see, most modern depictions of women in media patronize them.”

guest · 20:20
#woke-culture#audience-rejection#film-industry#media-patronizing