MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Andrew Doyle04 October 2025

Political Violence & The Lunatics of Your Own Side - Andrew Doyle - #1002

0Frameworks
5Insights

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take00:00

Your Side's Lunatics Make You Look Sillier Than the Opposition

The guest argues that the most damaging force to a political movement isn't its opposition, but the extremists within its own ranks. He contends that the mainstream left has failed to disavow the 'lunatics' in its house, leading to a dangerous erosion of boundaries and a normalization of violent rhetoric.

  • The greatest enemy of any political side is often its own extremists, not the opposing side.
  • The mainstream left has failed to distance itself from the 'hard left,' allowing violent rhetoric to be normalized.
  • When a crowd cheers a call for violence at a protest, it signals that such rhetoric has become acceptable within that movement.

“The lunatics on your own side make you look much sillier than the opposition ever could.”

Host · 00:25

“What I reacted to was the crowd cheering and applauding that. Because what that tells you is that violence and violent rhetoric has been normalized…”

Guest · 02:55
#political violence#culture war#extremism

Explainer· 1

Explainer02:00

How Violent Rhetoric Becomes Normalized in Movements

The guest explains that while every movement has a few bad actors, the real danger is when the broader community cheers on calls for violence. He uses a clip from a trans pride protest where an activist shouted 'punch them in the face' and the crowd's applause as a key example of this normalization.

  • A single bad actor is not the issue; the problem is when the entire crowd endorses violent speech.
  • Cheering for violence signals a movement's acceptance of it, making it a core part of its culture.
  • This normalization makes it harder for the movement to claim it stands for peace and justice.

“If I was at a parade of something that I really supported... and someone stood up and called for violence, I'd be like, 'Who's that?…”

Guest · 02:55
#free speech#activism#rhetoric

Q&A· 1

Q&A07:30

Why the Reaction to Charlie Kirk's Murder Was So Disturbing

The guest expresses deep personal distress over the reaction to the attempted assassination of Charlie Kirk, particularly the attempts to justify it by misrepresenting his views. He argues that this reaction reveals a profound malevolence.

  • The attempt to justify the attack by cherry-picking out-of-context clips is a form of 'hobgoblin-like behavior.'
  • The guest was personally shaken by the level of malice, which challenged his 'naive faith in humanity.'
  • The murder attempt felt like an attack on free speech itself, not just a political act.

“It's bothered me. Yeah, it's really bothered me because it's been relentless and it's just inhumane.”

Guest · 14:50
#free speech#media#violence

Tool· 1

Tool04:30

The FIRE Study on Tolerance for Political Violence

The guest cites a recent study by FIRE (Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression) which found a chilling trend: 25% of young, very liberal Americans believe political violence can sometimes be justified. This data point is central to his argument about the growing acceptance of violence.

  • The FIRE study is a key piece of evidence showing a tolerance for political violence among young liberals.
  • 25% of very liberal young Americans say violence can be justified to achieve political goals.
  • The trend is also increasing on the right, indicating a broader societal problem with tribalism.

“25% of very liberals say that violence can sometimes be justified in order to achieve political goals.”

Guest · 04:50
#free speech#youth#study

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway19:00

Wokeness Is Dying, But Authoritarianism Will Return

The guest argues that while 'wokeness' as a specific movement is in decline, the underlying human impulse toward authoritarianism will not disappear. It will simply manifest in a new form, potentially just as dangerous.

  • Support for 'wokeness' peaked in 2020 and has been declining since.
  • Key institutions like the Tavistock clinic and the UK Supreme Court have dealt significant blows to gender ideology.
  • The decline of one authoritarian movement does not mean the end of authoritarianism itself.

“Wokeness was simply the latest manifestation of authoritarianism, which is a natural impulse to humankind. And it emerges from the left and the right and…”

Guest · 21:10
#authoritarianism#woke#ideology