MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Richard Shotton05 August 2019

Some Very Important Effects In Advertising - Richard Shotton - #091

0Frameworks
10Insights

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster06:30

Most Ads Lie, So Honesty Stands Out

Contrary to the belief that all advertisers exaggerate, admitting a flaw can actually boost credibility. Most brands avoid this, making those who do more memorable and trustworthy.

If you admit a flaw, you've tangibly demonstrated your honesty, and then all your other claims become that much more believable.

Richard Shotton · 06:30
#advertising#credibility#marketing-strategy

Explainer· 3

Explainer03:30

Why Flaws Make Ads More Appealing

The Pratfall effect, identified by psychologist Elliot Aronson, shows that people find individuals or brands more likable when they display minor flaws. In advertising, admitting a weakness—like KFC saying 'Our fries suck'—can increase relatability and believability.

  • People rate performers as more likable if they make a small mistake after excelling.
  • Brands like VW, Avis, and Guinness have used self-deprecating ads to build trust.
  • Admitting a flaw signals honesty, making other claims more believable.
  • The flaw should be the 'mirror image' of a core strength (e.g., slow pour = quality).

The contestant is seen as significantly more appealing if people have heard the mistake as well as the amazing performance.

Richard Shotton · 04:30
#psychology#advertising#behavioral-science#pratfall-effect
Explainer11:30

How Effort Increases Perceived Value

The IKEA effect shows that people value things more when they put effort into them. General Mills learned this when their cake mix failed—until they added the step of cracking an egg, making it feel more meaningful.

  • Adding effort (like cracking an egg) signals love and care, increasing perceived value.
  • People associate ease with low emotional investment.
  • This principle applies to products like cold brew coffee poured slowly like Guinness.

They artificially make the cake mix more complicated... now you have to crack an egg into it. And now, by making it harder, once they've…

Richard Shotton · 13:00
#ikea-effect#behavioral-science#marketing#effort-signaling
Explainer34:30

How Context Changes Perceived Value

Consumers judge value relatively, not absolutely. Seedlip, a non-alcoholic gin, is priced at £25—expensive for a cordial but reasonable when compared to premium gin.

  • Price perception depends on what product category you're compared to.
  • Nespresso pods feel like good value next to Starbucks, but a £60 bag would not.
  • Changing the comparison set can increase willingness to pay tenfold.

If you stuck [Seedlip] next to Ribena... there's no way on earth any right-minded consumer would pay more than a fiver.

Richard Shotton · 35:00
#pricing#behavioral-economics#marketing-psychology

Story· 3

Story46:30

How French Music Sells More French Wine

In a supermarket experiment, playing French music increased French wine sales to 77% of total French/German wine sales. When German music played, German wine dominated. Yet 86% of shoppers denied being influenced.

  • Environmental cues like music subtly shape behavior.
  • Most people are unaware of what truly influences their choices.
  • Marketers should test behavior, not rely on self-reported data.

When the French music plays, 77% of the wine from those two countries is French, 27% German.

Richard Shotton · 47:00
#environmental-cues#music#consumer-behavior
Story58:30

The Lemon Juice Bank Robber Who Inspired a Bias

McArthur Wheeler robbed two banks with lemon juice on his face, believing it made him invisible to cameras. His extreme overconfidence inspired the Dunning-Kruger effect—the idea that unskilled people overestimate their abilities.

  • Wheeler tested his theory with a selfie but failed due to poor aim.
  • Dunning and Kruger studied why people lack self-awareness.
  • Novices overestimate; experts sometimes underestimate.

He smeared his face with lemon juice. Because his mate had told him that lemon juice is what's, you know, you make invisible ink out…

Richard Shotton · 59:00
#dunning-kruger#overconfidence#psychology
Story67:30

Julius Caesar Invented Premium Pricing

When captured by pirates, Caesar insisted they demand a higher ransom—50 units instead of 20—knowing the high price would boost his reputation. This is an early example of the Veblen effect: high price signals high quality.

  • Caesar used the ransom to build his public image.
  • He later returned, captured the pirates, and executed them.
  • The tactic mirrors modern luxury branding.

Caesar said, 'No, no, no, hang on. Don't ask for 20. I'm worth far more than that. Ask for 50.'

Richard Shotton · 67:30
#veblen-effect#pricing#storytelling

Q&A· 1

Q&A41:30

Why Ages Ending in 9 Trigger Big Decisions

People whose age ends in 9 (29, 39, 49, etc.) are more likely to make major life changes—like running their first marathon or joining an affair site—due to a psychological 'fresh start' mindset.

  • People approaching a new decade reflect on life progress.
  • Data shows spikes in marathons, infidelity, and even suicide at ages ending in 9.
  • Marketers can target this group more effectively and cheaply.

People were 48% more likely to do a marathon first time when their age ends in nine.

Richard Shotton · 42:30
#behavioral-science#life-transitions#marketing-targeting

Tool· 2

Tool14:30

Fake Loading Bars Build Trust

A designer adds a 3.5-second loading bar to spreadsheets to make them appear more sophisticated and trustworthy—even though it's just an animation.

  • Friction can signal effort and authority.
  • Users perceive slower processes as more thorough.
  • The illusion of complexity increases credibility.

That loading bar is always 3 and 1/2 seconds long. No matter how much data goes through because it's just an animation.

Richard Shotton · 15:00
#ux-design#friction#trust#psychological-tricks
Tool64:30

Ex-Pickpockets Warn Tourists

Ogilvy ran a campaign using reformed pickpockets to drop flyers in people's pockets, proving how easy it is to steal—making the warning more impactful than a sign.

  • The flyer read: 'I could have helped myself if I wanted to.'
  • It demonstrated risk more effectively than a warning sign.
  • Uses behavioral insight: people ignore general risks but respond to personal demonstrations.

They got the pickpocket to drop a little flyer in people's pockets saying, 'Well, it was easy enough for me to put this in your…

Richard Shotton · 64:30
#nudges#campaign#safety#behavioral-insight