MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Dr Jack Lewis11 June 2020

The Neuroscience Of The 7 Deadly Sins - Dr Jack Lewis - #182

2Frameworks
17Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster

Gluttony is not just food: the invisible calories in drink

The word gluttony comes from the Latin gluttire, to gulp, so it covers drink too, not just food. Lewis flags the large, uncounted sugar load in lager and vodka mixers, and how a daily glass of wine can quietly slide into a bottle. Obesity ages the brain's white matter by roughly ten years.

  • Gluttony derives from Latin 'to gulp' and includes all consumption through the mouth
  • Alcohol and mixers carry large, uncounted sugar calories
  • Obese white matter resembles that of someone ten years older
  • The reliable fix is not buying it, not resisting it at home

The word gluttony comes from the Latin gluttire, which means to gulp. It's not just food... it's drink too.

Dr Jack Lewis
#gluttony#alcohol#diet#brain-health
Myth Buster

You have zero conscious control over what arouses you

Lewis argues we have no conscious control over what makes us sexually excited, only over whether we act on it. A gay man cannot choose that a man arouses him; a straight man cannot decide to be otherwise. He uses this to argue the church's historic treatment of homosexuality was pernicious, and notes that under strict original doctrine any non-procreative sex counts as sodomy.

  • We control our actions, never the arousal trigger itself
  • Objective measures like plethysmography confirm arousal is involuntary
  • Under strict original doctrine, all non-procreative sex is sodomy
  • No one should feel guilty for feeling desire

No one should feel guilty for feeling sexual desire towards another person, because we have zero control over that.

Dr Jack Lewis
#lust#sexuality#free-will

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take

Vilification drives paedophilia underground and helps no one

Lewis makes a pragmatic argument: if the goal is protecting children, vilifying people with paedophilic urges is counterproductive because it leaves them nowhere to turn for help, so they suppress it or seek out others who normalise it. He notes a UK helpline where roughly half of calls go unanswered for lack of staffing, and questions making people culpable for thoughts they cannot control.

  • The pragmatic aim is reducing harm to children, not moral condemnation
  • Disgust drives urges underground where they can worsen
  • Sufferers fear a GP will report them, so they get no therapy
  • A UK helpline reportedly leaves about half of calls unanswered

Society's quite understandable attitude of disgust towards paedophiles only serves to drive them underground.

Dr Jack Lewis
#lust#society#mental-health#harm-reduction
Hot Take

The eighth deadly sin: overconsumption of technology

Asked to add an eighth sin, Lewis proposes ill-disciplined overconsumption of technology. Offloading memory to the internet weakens retention; constant screen use starves the empathy circuits that read faces and body language; and social media manufactures malicious envy. The vice is failing to ask whether your use is making you happier or more deflated.

  • Knowing you can look something up stops you retaining it
  • Heads-down screen use starves the empathy circuits that read faces
  • Social media drives negative, malicious envy via curated highlight reels
  • The test is whether use leaves you happier or more deflated

The excessive use of technology to the detriment of your well-being. That would be my eighth deadly sin of the modern age.

Dr Jack Lewis
#technology#social-media#empathy#attention

Explainer· 7

Explainer

Why the seven deadly sins are literally deadly

The through-line of the episode: each vice in excess makes people push you away, and social isolation is an all-cause mortality risk known since 1988. Lonely people die earlier of cancers and cardiovascular disease and suffer more depression and anxiety. Real friends who push back on your bad ideas are essential, not just nice to have.

  • Social isolation raises all-cause mortality, a fact established since 1988
  • One or two reliable friends matter more than 500 online followers
  • Friends stress-test your bonkers hypotheses and counter confirmation bias
  • Excess of any vice isolates you, closing the deadly loop

Social isolation is literally deadly... if you're socially isolated, you die earlier, and it's an all-cause mortality risk, loneliness.

Dr Jack Lewis
#loneliness#mortality#friendship#mental-health
Explainer

Pride, narcissism and the brain's pain button

Pride in moderation reinforces good behaviour in childhood, but in excess becomes narcissism, often rooted in poor self-esteem from neglectful or helicopter parenting and an 'undifferentiated sense of self'. fMRI shows narcissists' dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, the pain-generating region, fires harder to social rejection, so they feel slights more acutely and plot revenge.

  • Narcissism often stems from an undifferentiated sense of self
  • Both neglectful and helicopter parenting can cause it
  • Narcissists' DACC fires harder to social rejection, amplifying perceived offence
  • St Gregory called pride the queen and gateway to all other sins

When a narcissistic person is socially rejected, they feel the pain of that social rejection more acutely.

Dr Jack Lewis
#pride#narcissism#neuroscience#parenting
Explainer

Set-piece behaviours: the autopilot scripts that run us

Lewis's mother, a therapist, taught him the term 'set-piece behaviour' for the unconscious, scripted reactions our neuroses replay under pressure. It is why counsellors must have years of therapy themselves: their own set pieces interfere with helping others. Williamson likens it to a rehearsed move in sport that plays out step by step.

  • Set-piece behaviours are unconscious, scripted reactions triggered by situations
  • They interfere with objectivity, so therapists need therapy themselves
  • School of Life psychotherapists reportedly need five years of their own sessions
  • Naming the script is the first step to catching it

It's impossible to be an effective counsellor if you don't have counselling yourself, because your own neuroses come out in the way you did.

Dr Jack Lewis
#psychology#therapy#self-awareness
Explainer

The reproductive function of the female orgasm

Lewis explains that cilia, tiny hair-like extensions reaching into the fallopian tubes, waft sperm toward the tube containing the egg. A woman who enjoys sex with an emotionally connected partner is more likely to orgasm and therefore to direct sperm effectively, hinting at evolutionary mate selection. He adds a contested theory that the penis's coronal shape helps displace a rival's prior deposit.

  • Cilia in the fallopian tubes waft sperm toward the egg-bearing side
  • Orgasm may selectively favour sperm from a trusted partner
  • This suggests strict biological monogamy in humans is dubious
  • A contested theory links penis shape to sperm displacement

It wafts it into the one that the egg will be found in, over and above the one that didn't produce an egg.

Dr Jack Lewis
#lust#evolution#reproduction#biology
Explainer

Benign versus malicious envy: two ways to close the gap

Envy, the least fun vice, has a sense of injustice at its core and flags when we lag behind peers with a similar start in life. Benign envy prompts you to study the other person and improve; malicious envy prompts you to drag them down with gossip. The DACC pain circuit fires the moment envy strikes, making it the first link toward antisocial behaviour.

  • Envy alerts us that we are lagging behind comparable peers
  • Benign envy motivates self-improvement; malicious envy seeks others' downfall
  • Envy carries an inbuilt sense of injustice
  • The DACC pain region fires the instant envy arises

You can either pull yourself up by your bootstraps... or circulate malicious gossip and bring them tumbling down.

Dr Jack Lewis
#envy#motivation#neuroscience
Explainer

Greed, the isolated super-rich, and where money stops buying happiness

Lewis argues pure greed is nasty even before its antisocial effects: the endlessly wealthy self-isolate in gated communities and suffer higher rates of psychiatric problems. Money raises happiness only up to covering basic security; beyond that the endless pursuit of more works against contentment. Williamson cites Morgan Housel: being rich won't make you happy, but being poor can make you miserable.

  • The super-rich actively self-isolate, raising psychological distress
  • Income lifts happiness only up to meeting basic needs
  • Wealth brings the anxiety of having something to lose
  • Wealth is doing what you want, with whom, for as long as you want

Being rich won't make you happy, but being poor can make you miserable.

Chris Williamson
#greed#money#happiness#isolation
Explainer

Wrath, tit-for-tat escalation, and what 'an eye for an eye' really means

A modicum of wrath is legitimate self-defence, and 'an eye for an eye' actually means proportionality, that your response must match, not exceed, the offence. Lewis cites a shock-exchange study where the DACC pain signal correlated with how much people cranked up retaliation voltage, showing inner pain drives escalating revenge until things turn dark.

  • An eye for an eye means proportionate response, not maximal revenge
  • In a shock-exchange study, DACC activity tracked escalating retaliation
  • Inner pain, not just the offence, fuels revenge fantasies
  • 90% of murders are committed by men, though socialisation muddies the cause

That's all eye for an eye means... whatever ill has been done towards you, you need to be measured in your response.

Dr Jack Lewis
#wrath#revenge#neuroscience#aggression

Story· 1

Story

The brain tumour that switched paedophilia on and off

Lewis recounts the Burns and Swerdlow case: a responsible teacher developed paedophilic urges toward his stepdaughter and was jailed. A headache led to a brain scan revealing a large tumour; removing it dissolved the urges. When the tumour regrew, the urges and disinhibition returned. It illustrates that the issue was lost capacity to suppress urges, not the urges appearing from nowhere.

  • A tumour's presence tracked the man's paedophilic behaviour on and off
  • The mechanism was disinhibition, a lost ability to resist urges
  • It parallels the Texas bell-tower shooter's aggression-linked tumour
  • Rare cases like this let us see the brain-behaviour link cleanly

It's so rare to have a case where the paedophilic tendencies were switch on and offable according to the presence or absence of a tumour.

Dr Jack Lewis
#neuroscience#brain-tumour#disinhibition#case-study

Tool· 1

Tool

Gas your friends up: turn the impulse to reach out into a habit

Williamson shares a practical habit: whenever you think of a friend, miss them, or see them do something cool, message them immediately instead of taking the path of least resistance. Making support instinctive combats envy and strengthens the relationships that protect against isolation. He credits the phrase 'gas your friends up'.

  • Text friends the moment you think of or miss them
  • When you see a friend succeed, reach out rather than stay silent
  • Making support instinctive counters envy and complacency
  • For every person who says thanks, hundreds felt it and stayed quiet

If you ever miss your friends, the second that you think about missing them, text them.

Chris Williamson
#friendship#habits#connection

Takeaway· 4

Takeaway

Why ancient wisdom keeps beating cutting-edge research

Lewis and Williamson open on how much modern discovery merely rediscovers what ancient thinkers already worked out. A friend of Lewis's spent four and a half years of a PhD on healing spaces only to find the ancient Greeks had reached the same answers. They frame it through the Lindy effect and a Donald Kingsbury quote on tradition.

  • Tradition is a set of solutions for problems we have forgotten
  • Newer is not automatically better; social media is the least Lindy medium
  • Modern science is best used as a lens to separate ancient wheat from chaff
  • Rapid, superficial consumption stops people going deep

Tradition is a set of solutions for which we have forgotten the problems. Throw away the solution, and you get the problem back.

Chris Williamson
#ancient-wisdom#lindy-effect#philosophy
Takeaway

Be careful who you envy

Because social media shows a curated highlight reel, we envy people whose backstage lives may be miserable. Lewis's advice: you cannot summon or stop envy, but once it arises, evaluate whether the person is actually worthy of it. Williamson cites the Naval Ravikant idea that you must take the whole of someone's life, not cherry-pick their success, using Elon Musk as an example.

  • Social media manufactures envy by hiding people's real backstories
  • You cannot control feeling envy, only how you evaluate it afterward
  • Ask whether the envied person is truly worthy of it before ruminating
  • You cannot have someone's success piecemeal; you take the whole life or none

Be careful who you envy, because quite often the people that others envy project success... but behind the scenes, are they really great?

Dr Jack Lewis
#envy#social-media#comparison
Takeaway

The journey is the destination: intrinsic over extrinsic reward

Williamson describes a post-Love Island existential crisis that pushed him toward doing the podcast for its own sake, saying he would do it if no one listened. Lewis reinforces this with the German phrase der Weg ist das Ziel, the journey is the destination, arguing hobbies pursued for intrinsic reward promote well-being far more than status-chasing, whether or not you succeed.

  • Chris pivoted from decade-long commercial motivation to curiosity-driven work
  • Intrinsic reward beats extrinsic reward for well-being
  • Hobbies satisfy precisely because they never end and go nowhere but forward
  • Success in the endeavour is optional if you enjoy the process

The journey is the destination... you get huge amounts of intrinsic reward from the process of doing something that you enjoy.

Dr Jack Lewis
#fulfilment#hobbies#intrinsic-motivation
Takeaway

Sloth in moderation: why boring holidays and boredom are cleansing

A modicum of sloth prevents burnout; the brain and body need daily and weekly rest for deep cleaning and repair. Lewis warns against cramming every holiday full, because a dull holiday lets the brain maintain itself. Boredom, the absence of stimulation, is where original and eccentric ideas bubble up from the subconscious, so switching everything off can change your life.

  • A little laziness daily and weekly prevents burnout
  • Boring is cleansing: unstimulated brains do maintenance and repair
  • Boredom lets subconscious ideas surface into consciousness
  • You serve others from the overflowing saucer, not the cup

Switch it off for a whole day, bore yourself to death, and then see what emerges.

Dr Jack Lewis
#sloth#rest#boredom#creativity