MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Connor Beaton12 October 2023

Why Are Young Men Struggling So Much? - Connor Beaton - #692

0Frameworks
20Insights

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster24:30

The Myth of Male Vulnerability

Connor challenges the popular narrative that men's problems will disappear if they just 'open up.' He argues this framing is female-oriented, ignores real consequences of opening up to the wrong people, and misses that many men in therapy who later died by suicide were rated as low or no risk.

  • The narrative that 'just be vulnerable' fixes men's problems misses real risks, like being judged or a partner not knowing how to handle it.
  • 92% of UK men who died by suicide were in therapy; 80% of those were rated no-risk or low-risk.
  • Many women aren't equipped to receive male vulnerability because they never saw it modeled by fathers or grandfathers.
  • What women often actually want is for a man to know what's happening inside him and communicate it, not necessarily to be relied on to support him through it.

the myth is that all of men's problems will just disappear if men are just more vulnerable

Connor Beaton · 26:30

92% of men in the UK that had taken their lives were in therapy... 80% of those men... were labeled as no risk or low…

Connor Beaton · 25:00
#vulnerability#therapy#suicide#myth-buster

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take37:00

"If a Woman Has a Problem We Fix Society. If a Man Has One, We Tell Him to Fix Himself."

Chris reads a controversial post he wrote arguing that discussions of men's struggles get dismissed under a 'zero-sum' view of empathy, as if attention to men's problems must take away from women's. He argues checked-out, resentful men actually hurt women too by shrinking the pool of good partners.

  • Empathy isn't zero-sum: attention to men's struggles doesn't subtract from women's.
  • Apathetic, checked-out men contribute to the "no good men" problem women report.
  • Society routinely funds campaigns to fix systemic issues for other groups, but tells men to "just work harder."
  • The framing gap: a woman's problem prompts "what can we fix in society?"; a man's problem prompts "what can men do to fix themselves?"

if a woman has a problem we ask what can we do to fix Society if a man has a problem we ask what can…

Chris Williamson · 38:00
#empathy#gender#hot-take
Hot Take82:30

The Goal Isn't to Convince You of One Narrative, It's to Confuse You With All of Them

Chris argues that men navigating dominance, consent, and #MeToo-era expectations face contradictory messaging, and speculates the net effect, whether coordinated or not, is that people are fire-hosed with so many competing narratives that the truth becomes impossible to locate, leaving men anxious and checked out.

  • Men must calibrate sexual dominance against fear of being seen as a threat in the #MeToo era.
  • Chris says the effect of competing cultural narratives is that "the truth can no longer be ascertained," regardless of intent.
  • Connor adds that confusion itself is one of the most corrosive things to masculine confidence and assuredness.

the goal of this isn't to convince anybody of any one particular narrative it's to fire hose you with so many narratives that the truth…

Chris Williamson · 82:30

confusion is one of the most toxic things for that masculine body

Connor Beaton · 86:00
#culture-war#narrative#confusion

Explainer· 9

Explainer00:00

The One Rule of Men: Never Talk About Struggling

Connor explains the unspoken rule men live by: no matter what's going wrong, you don't talk about it. He compares it to Fight Club's first rule and argues this suppression convinces men that things won't change until they hit rock bottom.

  • The "one rule of men" is: don't talk about being a man who's struggling.
  • Men are taught that suppressing anger, anxiety, sadness and grief long enough makes them stronger.
  • This suppression creates a part of a man that actively works against him.
  • Many men become convinced change only comes after hitting rock bottom.

the first rule of men is that you don't talk about what it's like to be a man specifically a man who is suffering or…

Connor Beaton · 00:00

seeking strength through suppression

Chris Williamson · 02:00
#masculinity#emotional-suppression#vulnerability
Explainer09:30

Why Men Are Conditioned to Hide Their Struggles

Connor breaks down the roots of male emotional suppression: evolutionary survival pressure, the belief that being 'put together' attracts women, competition-based male friendships that punish admitting weakness, and generational trauma passed down from men who fought in the World Wars.

  • Evolutionary pressure historically demanded toughness to survive.
  • A social belief that being 'put together' is what attracts women.
  • Competitive male friendships mean admitting weakness feels like losing.
  • WWII-generation men were taught to suppress emotions to survive combat, then passed that hardness down through generations.

if I'm competing with you... the last thing that I want you to know... is where I feel weak

Connor Beaton · 10:30
#masculinity#evolutionary-psychology#generational-trauma
Explainer13:30

The Unconscious Status Competition Between Men

Connor and Chris discuss how men constantly size each other up in the background of even close friendships, assessing physique, watches, and hierarchy, while rarely admitting it out loud, because talking about status openly is itself low-status.

  • Male competition is largely unconscious, unlike women's more overt social comparison.
  • A friend's therapist noted that comparing yourself to other men in a hierarchy is baked into being a man.
  • Admitting you're competing with someone is itself "low status"; the game is lost by talking about it.
  • This makes it harder for men to open up about financial, sexual, or relational struggles to friends they're unconsciously competing with.

status is a game that you lose the second that you talk about it

Chris Williamson · 20:30
#male-competition#status#friendship
Explainer21:00

What Primatologists Learned About Alpha Chimps

Chris relays insight from a primatologist guest showing that alpha chimps who lead through dominance and aggression actually have shorter lifespans and shorter reigns; the alphas who lead longest do so through coherence and prestige, not force.

  • Aggressive, dominance-based alpha chimps tend to have shorter lifespans and shorter leadership tenures.
  • Longer-leading alphas rule through building coherence within the tribe, not aggression.
  • Reframes "alpha" status as being about prestige and group cohesion rather than dominance.

the alphas that tend to lead longer are actually not ruling through dominance they're actually ruling through coherence... and Prestige

Connor Beaton · 21:30
#primatology#leadership#dominance
Explainer44:00

The Vacancy: Why So Many Boys Grow Up Without Male Role Models

Connor describes how a boy can pass through childhood, education, and even therapy without meaningful male influence, raised by a single mother, taught by mostly female teachers, and later seeing a mostly-female therapist, leaving a psychological 'vacancy' where masculine mentorship should be.

  • One in four kids grow up without a father in the household.
  • Education is dominated by female teachers; roughly 75% of therapists are women.
  • A boy can go through childhood, education, and mental health support without real male influence.
  • Mentorship and initiation by older men has been a cross-cultural historical norm that's been "strip mined" out of modern life.

you can literally go through childhood education mental health support and not be influenced by any men

Connor Beaton · 46:00
#fatherlessness#mentorship#role-models
Explainer58:00

How Fatherlessness Breeds the 'Nice Guy' Syndrome

Connor explains that boys without a father figure lack something to orient themselves toward or against, so many default to seeking approval from women instead, becoming people-pleasers who orient their identity around female validation rather than developing it independently.

  • Boys typically orient themselves "toward" or "in opposition to" their father's example; without either, they lack a reference point.
  • Without that, many boys orient toward earning affirmation from women instead, becoming classic "nice guys."
  • This can flip into resentment and pushing against women instead of against a father figure or other men.
  • Connor connects this pattern to some of the online "manosphere" backlash movements.

they either Orient in opposition of their father or in repetition of their father

Connor Beaton · 59:30
#fatherlessness#people-pleasing#psychology
Explainer62:30

Why Boys Raised Without Fathers Struggle to Set Boundaries

Connor explains a developmental pattern: fathers typically model structure, order, and limitations, while mothers model nurturing and acceptance. Without a father's structure, boys learn to acquiesce to their mother to stay safe and loved, a pattern that can echo into adult relationships.

  • Fathers generally provide structure, order, and limitation; mothers provide nurturing, care, and acceptance.
  • Boys without fatherly boundary-setting learn to acquiesce rather than assert "no."
  • Acquiescing becomes a safety strategy when the mother is a boy's only caregiver or lifeline.
  • This dynamic often carries into adult romantic relationships as difficulty asserting needs.

fathers generally speaking play the role of structure and orientation towards order... whereas with mothers generally it's about nurturing care and acceptance

Connor Beaton · 63:30
#parenting#boundaries#psychology
Explainer68:30

The Silent Pressure on Men to Always Be 'Ready'

Chris and Connor discuss the double standard where women's body image struggles have become culturally normalized to talk about, while men are expected to always be sexually available and high-performing, with little space to admit low libido, performance anxiety, or their own preferences in bed.

  • Female body image conversations have become culturally normalized (e.g. "feral girl summer"); equivalent male conversations haven't.
  • Men are presumed sexual "protagonists" who should be ready on command; turning down sex reads very differently than when women do.
  • Talking about desired sexual frequency or fantasies is a distinct, harder form of vulnerability for men.
  • Pop culture normalizes male rejection-seeking (e.g. Homer Simpson gags) but not male reluctance.

there is an expectation that men are the sexual protagonists and women are the sexual Gatekeepers even within a relationship

Chris Williamson · 68:30
#sex#male-psychology#double-standard
Explainer73:30

Why Chronic Stress Kills Sexual Performance

Connor explains the physiological chain from chronic work and relationship stress to poor sexual performance: sympathetic nervous system dominance drops testosterone and floods the body with cortisol and adrenaline, none of which are conducive to getting or staying hard.

  • Chronic stress pushes the nervous system into sympathetic dominance.
  • This suppresses testosterone and disrupts sleep.
  • Cortisol and adrenaline are not conducive to erections or performance.
  • Modern always-on, overcaffeinated lifestyles set men up to underperform sexually, then feel more anxious about it.

if you're stressed you getting hard is going to be a challenge if you're stressed you staying hard it's going to be a challenge

Connor Beaton · 74:00
#stress#testosterone#sexual-health

Story· 3

Story07:00

Chateau Walmart: The Night a Friend Revealed His Suicide Attempt

Connor recounts living out of his car after his life collapsed, then opening up to a college friend about his infidelity and career failure. His friend's response, 'thank you,' revealed he had attempted suicide six weeks earlier, exposing how both men had been performing strength while suffering alone.

  • Connor lived out of his 2007 Pontiac G5 ("Chateau Walmart") after his life collapsed, including an affair he'd been caught in.
  • He decided to open up fully to a college friend about everything that had happened.
  • The friend thanked him, then revealed he had tried to take his own life six weeks earlier.
  • Both men had been performing 'having it together' while privately struggling, illustrating a broader existential aloneness among men.

he looked at me and he said thank you and then he proceeded to tell me that he had tried to take his own life…

Connor Beaton · 08:00
#story#suicide#vulnerability#friendship
Story51:30

The Reverse Role Model: Learning What Not to Become

Chris shares his idea of the 'negative role model,' learning who not to be from older men around you rather than who to be, recounting overhearing crude, dismissive conversations about infidelity and relationships from older teammates at his cricket club as a teenager.

  • Chris spent ages 13-18 around older cricket club teammates, most 25-plus.
  • Some were good influences; others became "reverse role models" showing him what not to become, like gambling problems or poor treatment of partners.
  • He overheard casual, dismissive stories about infidelity told as jokes rather than real disclosures.
  • The concept: seeing what you don't want to be like can be as valuable as a positive role model.

I came up with this idea called the negative role model or the reverse role model

Chris Williamson · 52:00
#mentorship#story#cricket
Story75:00

Chris's Testosterone Went From 495 to 1,096 With a Few Simple Fixes

Chris shares his own bloodwork story: starting a preventative-medicine protocol with a blood testing/hormone optimization company revealed low-normal testosterone at 495, and simple interventions (Boron, pharmaceutical-grade magnesium glycinate, more organ meat) more than doubled it to 1,096, transforming his mood, energy, and libido.

  • Chris's testosterone tested at 495 (low end of "normal" range) despite training heavily.
  • Protocol included Boron to free up bound testosterone, pharmaceutical-grade magnesium glycinate, and more organ meat, no TRT involved.
  • A retest showed 1,096, more than double his starting level.
  • He describes the mood, energy, and libido shift as "palpable," realizing his prior baseline wasn't actually normal.

495 came back at 495... I got my results back about two weeks ago and it was at 1,096... I've more than doubled my testosterone

Chris Williamson · 75:30
#testosterone#hormones#biohacking

Q&A· 2

Q&A30:00

"Acceptable Masculinity Sounds Like Stereotypical Femininity"

Chris cites journalist Christine Emba's Washington Post line arguing that when society does offer an 'acceptable' version of masculinity, it's really just femininity relabeled, reinforcing the idea that men are treated as defective women rather than understood on their own terms.

  • Christine Emba: acceptable masculinity, when offered at all, 'sounds an awful lot like stereotypical femininity.'
  • Connor connects this to the American Psychological Association framing 'traditional masculinity' as inherently harmful.
  • Both agree modern therapy often implicitly treats men as failing to be women.

to the extent that any acceptable version of masculinity is ever put forward it sounds an awful lot like stereotypical femininity

Christine Emba (quoted by Chris Williamson) · 30:00
#masculinity#media#quote
Q&A78:30

Women Want More Sexual Dominance Than Men Think They Should Show

Chris references researcher Aella's study finding that, on average, women want men to be more sexually dominant than men feel comfortable being, a result Chris says he replicated informally on his own Instagram audience, which Connor ties back to low testosterone and cultural messaging discouraging assertiveness.

  • Aella's research found women, on average, want more sexual dominance from men than men want to display.
  • Chris ran an informal poll on his Instagram and got the same result.
  • Connor links the gap partly to low testosterone reducing drive and confidence.
  • Men also face conflicting cultural messaging that discourages displaying dominance at all.

on average women want men to be more sexually dominant in the bedroom than men want to be sexually dominant in the bedroom

Chris Williamson · 79:00
#sex#dominance#research

Tool· 1

Tool92:00

Connor Beaton's Book 'Men's Work' and ManTalks.com

Connor points listeners to his book 'Men's Work,' written deliberately with integration exercises and questions so readers do real work rather than passively read, plus his platform ManTalks for further resources.

  • Book: "Men's Work", includes questions and integration exercises, not just passive reading.
  • Resources available at mantalks.com and Instagram @mantalks.

I wrote it in a way where I wanted guys to have real work to do as they read through the book

Connor Beaton · 92:30
#book#resource#mentorship

Takeaway· 2

Takeaway30:30

Young Men and Women Are Politically Diverging Fast

Chris notes a growing trend of liberal women wanting traditional dating behaviors only from conservative men, alongside data showing school-age girls trending liberal and boys trending conservative, setting up future friction as this generation reaches dating and family age.

  • A TikTok trend shows liberal women complaining only conservative men still do traditional dating gestures like paying and opening doors.
  • Girls are diverging toward liberal views and boys toward conservative views at a growing rate.
  • Roughly a third of Republicans and half of Democrats fear their child will marry across party lines.

there's going to be some awkward Thanksgiving dinners in a couple of decades time

Chris Williamson · 31:00
#politics#dating#generational
Takeaway87:30

Confession Is the First Step to Any Real Change

Connor closes with a Carl Jung line, that confession and admission is the universal first step of any therapeutic, spiritual, or transformational process, and applies it directly to men: naming the things you don't want to talk about is what starts actual psychological resilience.

  • Carl Jung: confession is the first step in any therapeutic or psychological process, mirrored in religious and spiritual traditions.
  • For men, "confessing" means naming the job you hate, the insecurity you hide, or the decision you regret.
  • Bringing internal truth out loud is what allows you to actually work with and reshape it.

the first step in any therapeutic or psychological modality is confession

Connor Beaton · 87:30
#psychology#personal-growth#quote