MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Sadia Khan16 October 2023

Why Is Modern Dating Such A Mess? - Sadia Khan - #694

0Frameworks
18Insights

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 3

Myth Buster01:00

Love Isn't Toxic — Your Behavior In It Is

Sadia argues the "love is toxic" narrative comes from people who just left bad relationships and blame love itself instead of their own choices. She also points out that commercial incentives — OnlyFans, porn, cosmetic surgery — profit from convincing people independence beats love.

  • People define all of love by how their last relationship ended, like judging a whole movie by a bad ending
  • "My ex is a narcissist" is used to dodge responsibility for one's own toxic behavior
  • Pain (things that happen to you) differs from suffering (the emotional consequence of poor decisions)
  • Independence sells — OnlyFans, porn, and cosmetic surgery all profit from convincing people love isn't necessary

the love isn't toxic it's how we behave in love and how we behave when vulnerable that creates toxicity

Sadia Khan · 01:30

suffering is a reminder that you made wrong choices

Sadia Khan · 04:30
#love#relationships#culture#marketing
Myth Buster26:30

"Nice Guys" Don't Fail Because They're Too Nice

Sadia reframes the "nice guy" problem: it isn't niceness that repels women, it's weak boundaries and no willingness to walk away. Women lose respect for men who let them make every decision, because it makes them feel unprotected.

  • Nice guys avoid setting boundaries and won't walk away from bad behavior — that's the actual problem, not kindness
  • Women feel angry, not flattered, when a man is "too nice" because it signals weakness
  • Manipulative women prefer boundary-less men; women wanting genuine connection want a man with a backbone

it's not about being nice it's about a lack of masculinity

Sadia Khan · 26:45

if you let a woman make all the decisions for you she'll slowly start to hate you

Sadia Khan · 27:15
#dating#masculinity#boundaries
Myth Buster96:30

Body Count Doesn't Matter — Rejection Rate Does

Sadia reframes the body-count debate: the real signal of character isn't how many people someone has slept with, but how selective they've been relative to the opportunities they had, i.e. their rejection rate.

  • A low body count can simply mean low opportunity, not virtue; a high one can coexist with high selectivity given more opportunity
  • The better question is how many advances someone turned down, not how many they accepted
  • A practical proxy: notice how excited someone gets when the opposite sex pays them attention

body count really has to depend on the person's ability to say no to sex

Sadia Khan · 99:00
#dating#body-count#relationships

Hot Take· 3

Hot Take05:00

Red Pill Men and Anti-Love Feminists Are the Same Person

Sadia argues that vocal "red pill" men and outspoken anti-love feminists share the same underlying pathology — both use rejection of love as an ego-defense mechanism, and both, in her view, tend to feel personally undesirable to the opposite sex.

  • "When you feel like you can't access something, the best way to defend your ego is to pretend you don't want it"
  • Both cohorts often personally believe they're undesirable to the opposite gender
  • She jokes the two groups "should get together" because they're a near-perfect psychological match

the only way to get rid of that feeling of being undesired is to pretend you don't desire the opposite gender

Sadia Khan · 05:45
#red-pill#feminism#self-esteem#dating
Hot Take105:30

If You Got Cheated On, You Probably Ignored the Red Flags

Sadia takes a controversial stance that infidelity is rarely a surprise: cheaters reveal their values — past behavior, views on monogamy, porn habits — early on, and getting cheated on is usually the price of ignoring those signals.

  • Cheaters show who they are from day one through stated values and past behavior
  • She argues it's nearly impossible to reach years of infidelity without unconsciously "consenting" to red flags along the way
  • Framed as a choice: knowingly accept someone's known risk profile, or don't ignore the warning signs

a cheating woman shows you every red flag from day one if you choose to ignore red flags you'll pay the price in life

Sadia Khan · 105:45
#infidelity#relationships#red-flags
Hot Take117:00

AI Girlfriends Are 'the New Version of Porn' — And More Dangerous

Reacting to an article about AI girlfriend apps like Replika and Eva AI, Sadia argues that stripping the human element from intimacy mirrors a dehumanizing mindset, and predicts men retreating into AI companionship while women retreat from dating altogether rather than "stepping up."

  • Compares the mindset behind AI-girlfriend use to that of a rapist: dehumanizing the other party for gratification
  • Predicts men who retreat into AI companionship become less "eligible," while women respond by giving up on men rather than competing with AI
  • Frames excessive comfort broadly as "the killer of joy," contrasting it with children who walk for water having less reported depression

we are creating a society of rapists that's essentially what we're doing

Sadia Khan · 119:45

comfort is actually the killer of joy

Chris Williamson · 126:15
#ai#dating#technology#culture

Explainer· 9

Explainer06:30

Why Rejecting Love Actually Deepens Depression

Sadia explains that humans are wired for connection, so deliberately warding off love caps your potential and manifests as depression and anxiety. She cites studies showing partner touch reduces labor pain and co-sleeping reduces nighttime awakenings.

  • Capping your potential — physically, emotionally, psychologically — leads to slow, steady depression
  • Studies show women feel less pain in labor while holding a partner's hand
  • Studies show people who sleep with a partner have fewer "micro-awakenings" at night
  • The body craves connection even after you've psychologically convinced yourself you don't want it

whenever we cap our potential ... it will lead to a slow and steady depression

Sadia Khan · 07:00
#love#mental-health#depression#evolutionary-psychology
Explainer08:00

Why You Sleep Worse in Hotels (and Better Next to a Partner)

Chris and Sadia discuss the evolutionary basis of "micro-awakenings" — brief returns toward consciousness during sleep that happen when the brain doesn't fully trust its environment is safe — explaining poor hotel sleep and better sleep near a partner.

  • Nomadic ancestors slept lighter away from home because a new location's safety wasn't assured
  • The sound of a crackling fire or a snoring dog reduces micro-awakenings (fire scares predators, dogs act as an early warning system)
  • Referenced from Johann Hari's book Lost Connections

if you have the sound of a crackling fire or the sound of snoring dogs both of those reduce micro awakenings

Chris Williamson · 08:45
#sleep#evolutionary-psychology#science
Explainer10:00

The Trauma Pattern Behind Sex Work

Sadia explains her clinical view that many women in sex work have histories of childhood sexual abuse, and that monetizing sex is a way to minimize the significance of what was done to them — but it leaves them struggling to value sexual loyalty in relationships.

  • Minimizing the importance of sex ("it's just an activity") functions as an ego defense against trauma
  • Monetizing sex reduces its emotional weight, making fidelity feel less essential to them
  • This pattern often produces emotionally disconnected, short-lived relationships and affects their parenting

escorts are porn addicts with money

Sadia Khan · 12:15
#sex-work#trauma#psychology
Explainer11:30

Why Emotionally Avoidant Men Turn to Escorts

Sadia describes men who pay for escorts as typically highly avoidant, with roots in emotional disconnect from their own upbringing, which is why they skip the emotional labor real intimacy requires and go straight to a transactional exchange.

  • Men who pay for sex often had emotional disconnect in their own household growing up
  • Emotionally intelligent men feel uncomfortable having sex with someone who doesn't want to be there
  • The shared emotional disconnect in escort and client is why the pair sometimes end up falling in love

the man that skipped that emotional intelligence and just wants pleasure will not even think about the emotional trauma that got her to this position

Sadia Khan · 12:45
#sex-work#psychology#masculinity
Explainer20:00

The Game Theory Behind Slut-Shaming and Simp-Shaming

Chris proposes that slut-shaming (mostly from women) and simp-shaming (mostly from men) are mirror-image mechanisms for protecting the "price" of the resource each sex holds. Sadia connects it to intrasexual competition, confirming only attractive or threatening women get shamed.

  • Women slut-shame to keep the "price" of sex from other women high; men simp-shame to keep the value of male resource-provision from hitting zero
  • Only attractive or threatening women tend to get slut-shamed — less attractive women who sleep around rarely face the same backlash
  • This is an example of intrasexual selection: verbal aggression directed at same-sex rivals perceived as a threat

men are concerned with resources without sex

Chris Williamson · 21:15

people only slut shame attractive women

Sadia Khan · 22:15
#slut-shaming#evolutionary-psychology#dating
Explainer24:00

Why Female Friendships Are More Fragile Than Male Ones

Sadia and Chris discuss research (citing Joyce Benenson's work) showing women can be more verbally hostile to same-sex rivals, especially when single, rooted in the idea that women's ancestral security came from a resource-providing partner rather than a coalition of peers.

  • A cited study found male basketball opponents showed more physical affection to each other than female teammates did
  • Single women tend to be more verbally hostile to each other than partnered women, who are out of the "competition zone"
  • Sadia says she gets significant hate from women online for not "siding with women" enough, based on personal experience

male opponents showed more physical affection to each other than female compatriots

Sadia Khan · 24:30
#friendship#women#evolutionary-psychology
Explainer39:30

Why Men and Women Misread Each Other's Attraction

Chris explains the evolutionary psychology finding, citing David Buss, that men systematically over-perceive women's attraction to them while women under-perceive men's attraction to them — a "failure of cross-sex mind reading" shown reliably in speed-dating data.

  • Men's "smoke alarm" logic: better to falsely assume attraction often than miss a real signal, since a false positive is cheap
  • Women underrate male attraction in speed-dating studies relative to what the men actually reported feeling
  • This bias explains many workplace and dating misreadings, including unwanted advances

men over perceive the level of attraction that they believe women have toward them and women under perceive the level of attraction that men have…

Chris Williamson · 39:45
#attraction#evolutionary-psychology#dating
Explainer82:00

Why Attractive Women Get Labeled 'Crazy'

Sadia explains that very attractive women are exposed to a skewed sample of male behavior — men willing to break rules or take big risks to access them — which erodes their trust and makes them appear more suspicious or intense in relationships, rather than inherently unstable.

  • Attractive women see men behave in extreme, rule-breaking ways to access them, distorting their sense of "normal" male behavior
  • This lost naivety makes them read innocent situations (a colleague, the gym) as potential threats
  • As looks fade, this can hit harder for women whose identity was built around appearance

she sees men as more dangerous than they are and therefore she thinks her partner is more sexual than he might be

Sadia Khan · 83:15
#attraction#psychology#women
Explainer92:30

Why Men Struggle When Their Partner Out-Earns Them

Sadia cites research that men produce more cortisol and less testosterone around partners who out-earn them, making them less attracted and less inclined to invest — and argues that investment, not money itself, is what drives men to fall in love.

  • Studies show men produce more cortisol around higher-earning partners, denting testosterone and attraction
  • Men invest less in higher-earning partners, and investment — not need — is what builds male attachment
  • Lower investment makes leaving easier for the man, while the higher-earning woman has invested emotionally and struggles more

when men are with women that earn more than them they produce more cortisol

Sadia Khan · 93:00

the more they invest in something the more they attach to it

Sadia Khan · 93:30
#relationships#money#gender-dynamics

Story· 3

Story14:00

What Running Nightclubs Taught Sadia About Strippers and Emotional Disconnect

Sadia recounts observing strippers while running nightclubs at university, noticing that women whose jobs required treating men as "resources to be extracted from" struggled to separate that transactional mode from genuine personal relationships.

  • Strippers ran men like a "sales funnel," using tricks to extract money from them
  • That transactional lens bled into their personal relationships and ability to connect emotionally
  • Sex workers tend to respect a man they have to financially support (like a bouncer) more than a wealthy CEO, because his investment signals he can be manipulated

they are ruthless with how they take money from men

Sadia Khan · 15:00

the man that provides for a stripper there's a stupidity in that

Sadia Khan · 17:00
#sex-work#nightlife#relationships
Story31:30

The Succession Line That Nails Why 'Dating Down' Backfires

Chris recalls a scene from Succession where a father tells his daughter she married a man beneath her because she's terrified of being betrayed. Sadia says marrying "down" to avoid infidelity risk actually raises the odds of the relationship failing, since it denies the mutual value both partners need.

  • Marrying someone "beneath you" to feel safe from cheating doesn't solve the deeper need for equal value in a relationship
  • The lower-status partner's own low self-esteem can eventually drive them to seek external validation or betray the relationship
  • True connection requires both partners bringing equal value and choosing each other, not "they can't do better"

you married a man that's beneath you because you're terrified of being betrayed

Chris Williamson · 32:15

if I marry someone beneath me to prevent him cheating on me ... you almost guarantee the divorce

Sadia Khan · 33:00
#marriage#infidelity#tv#relationships
Story80:30

The Dr. Money Twins Case and What It Suggests About Gender Identity

Sadia recounts the infamous David Reimer ("Dr. Money") case — a boy raised as a girl after a botched circumcision — who felt increasingly male through childhood and reverted at puberty, eventually taking his own life. She uses it to argue for caution around pre-puberty gender interventions.

  • The child, raised as a girl from infancy, reported feeling suicidal and increasingly male-identified as puberty approached
  • On learning the truth, he returned to living as a boy, which she reads as puberty triggering self-discovery regardless of upbringing
  • She argues blocking puberty pre-emptively could interfere with that self-discovery process

as soon as puberty hit in completely a boy again

Sadia Khan · 81:45
#gender#psychology#history