MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Jessica Baum15 November 2025

Why We Fall for the Wrong People - Jessica Baum - #1020

0Frameworks
19Insights

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster19:30

Why We Keep Attracting Partners Who Repeat Our Childhood Wounds

Jessica corrects the popular idea of 'manifesting' relationships — what actually happens is the nervous system gravitates toward familiar dynamics from childhood, even painful ones, because that's what the system recognizes and expects, not because it's good for you.

  • People often say they 'manifested' a partner or job, but it's really the nervous system pulling toward the familiar
  • This happens regardless of whether the familiar pattern was healthy or traumatic
  • People from neglectful/abusive homes often unconsciously recreate those same dynamics in adult relationships and jobs
  • Becoming conscious of original wounds and patterns is the first step to breaking trauma bonds

We tend to recreate our familiar... and ironically repeats the very trauma that they experienced.

Jessica Baum · 21:30

It feels so [expletive] cosmically unfair that our nervous systems confuse familiarity with safety.

Chris Williamson · 22:00
#trauma#attachment#myth-busting#relationships
Myth Buster31:00

Chaos Isn't Chemistry: Why Intensity Gets Mistaken for Love

Jessica busts the idea that a spark of chaos or intensity in a new relationship equals real compatibility. Intensity — including love bombing and euphoric brain chemicals — can feel like love but is actually neither true vulnerability nor closeness, and people are especially drawn to it when it matches their own familiar chaos.

  • Intensity/chemistry (love bombing, fast emotional closeness) can feel euphoric but isn't true vulnerability or closeness
  • People are attracted to intensity that matches their own 'familiar,' even if it isn't visible on the surface
  • Real safety can initially feel vulnerable or even boring compared to chaotic intensity
  • A person who received neglect and then meets someone who 'floods' them with attention may stay hooked even when the relationship later turns abusive

I would say it's intensity with chemistry... someone getting close really fast — all of that can feel like love, but it's not true vulnerability…

Jessica Baum · 31:30

Familiarity is not safety, it is familiarity.

Chris Williamson · 34:00
#dating#myth-busting#attachment#chemistry

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take14:30

Why Getting Rich Won't Fix What You Think It Will

Chris argues that money not buying happiness is an 'unteachable lesson' — people assume rich people are lying when they say it didn't fix their internal problems, but there's no secret conspiracy; it's genuinely true and only learned by experience, not persuasion.

  • People assume wealthy people who say 'money didn't fix my happiness' are being ungrateful or dishonest
  • There's no hidden 'rich person cabal' hiding the truth — they're telling the truth
  • Chris argues it may be faster to get rich and discover this than to try to logically dispense with the belief beforehand
  • Jessica connects it to Maslow's hierarchy — below a survival threshold, money does matter; above it, happiness becomes relative

Unless there's some weird cabal... that tells them once they become rich to tell all the poor people money won't fix your happiness problems... you…

Chris Williamson · 15:00

It's these stories we're telling ourselves that when I get here... then we're going to be happy. And that's just an illusion.

Jessica Baum · 17:00
#money#happiness#success
Hot Take51:00

Why Vulnerability Is Especially Dangerous-Feeling for Men

Chris and Jessica discuss why healing attachment wounds is uniquely hard for men: masculinity is culturally defined by emotional control, guys fear being seen as weak by other men and fear their vulnerability could drive a partner away, so most swallow it instead — despite this being the very thing that would let them heal.

  • Almost every definition of masculinity includes emotional mastery/control, making vulnerability feel like a threat to identity
  • Men fear both peer judgment (looking weak to other men) and partner abandonment if they show emotion
  • Chris cites that a large share of men who died by suicide had already sought some form of help — suggesting 'just talk about it' isn't sufficient advice on its own
  • Jessica: research shows vulnerability, though the scariest thing most people do, is what actually changes people's lives

It's actually a lot harder for men to heal because being vulnerable as a man was not even supported and it feels very dangerous for…

Jessica Baum · 51:30

It's evident that 'just talk about it, bro' isn't working.

Chris Williamson · 53:30
#men#vulnerability#masculinity#mental-health

Explainer· 10

Explainer01:30

Secure Attachment Is Borrowed From Other People's Nervous Systems

Jessica explains that secure attachment isn't self-generated — it's built by being around people who have a 'window of tolerance' and internalizing their sense of nervous-system safety over time. Without that exposure, insecure attachment styles develop instead.

  • Secure attachment comes from people around you who have a 'window of tolerance' (a stable, regulated nervous system)
  • The more you internalize others' calm, the more safety you feel in the wider world
  • Without that internalized safety, insecure attachment styles form

Secure attachment is built from people who have a sense of safety within their nervous system and they're around you and you've internalized that.

Jessica Baum · 01:30
#attachment#nervous-system#psychology
Explainer02:30

The Body Signals That Tell You a Relationship Feels Unsafe

Jessica lists the physical sensations that signal a person's nervous system has registered a relationship as unsafe — gut-dropping, racing heart, feeling smothered, fear of losing yourself, and abandonment fear — all of which show up through small everyday behaviors with a partner.

  • Unsafety shows up somatically: gut dropping, heart racing, feeling smothered, fear of losing yourself
  • These sensations surface through small daily behaviors with a close partner, not just big events

Everything from your gut dropping, your heart racing, feeling like the ball's going to drop, feeling smothered, feeling like you're going to lose yourself, feeling…

Jessica Baum · 02:30
#nervous-system#relationships#somatic
Explainer03:00

Why a Partner's 'Blank Stare' Sets Off Alarm Bells

Jessica identifies the 'blank stare' — a partner dissociating or checking out mid-conversation — as a small, easy-to-miss behavior that triggers a biological danger response. She ties it back to infant research on caregivers who go emotionally unavailable.

  • When a partner dissociates/checks out during conversation, the nervous system reads it as danger
  • Connection is framed as a biological imperative, not just a preference
  • Mirrors what infants experience when a primary caregiver checks out — referenced as the 'still face' / blank stare experiment

When you're really engaging with someone and they dissociate and kind of check out, my system will register: 'Oh my god, you're not with me…

Jessica Baum · 03:00
#nervous-system#attachment#communication
Explainer03:30

Inner Protectors: Why We Numb Out With Wine, Work, or Scrolling

Jessica explains 'inner protectors' — compulsive behaviors like workaholism, drinking, exercise, or vaping that people develop to avoid feeling difficult emotions. She's careful to note these behaviors aren't inherently bad, only when they're used repeatedly to dodge deeper feelings.

  • Protectors are behaviors we do compulsively/unconsciously to avoid uncomfortable internal feelings
  • Examples: drinking, exercising, workaholism, vaping, internet use
  • The behaviors aren't the problem — using them repeatedly to avoid processing feelings is
  • Jessica names workaholism as her own primary protector

It's when we turn to them over and over and over as a way to avoid what's going on inside that they become ways we…

Jessica Baum · 04:00
#coping-mechanisms#psychology#emotions
Explainer05:00

Why High-Achieving Women Often Feel Unsafe or Disconnected Inside

Jessica explains why so many outwardly strong, independent women feel disconnected internally: cultural pressure pushes people into left-hemisphere 'doing' mode (productivity, self-sufficiency) at the expense of the right-hemisphere relational mode, leaving them successful but lonely.

  • Culture pushes people (especially women) toward left-hemisphere traits: independence, self-sufficiency, productivity
  • Living in that mode means operating in chronic survival/sympathetic activation, disconnected from deep relating
  • Jessica personally chased success and found it didn't deliver happiness — relationships did
  • Independence looks rewarded externally (meritocracy, status) while quietly generating internal disconnection

We shift into our left hemispheres and we become like productive little doers... but we're in survival mode most of the time and we're not…

Jessica Baum · 05:00

It's this prophylactic that makes life much grayer but kind of more predictable... because it's on your shoulders.

Chris Williamson · 06:30
#women#success#nervous-system#hemispheres
Explainer08:30

The 'Left-Shifted' Brain and the Loneliness Epidemic

Jessica ties chronic sympathetic activation and left-hemisphere dominance directly to the modern loneliness epidemic, citing that roughly 75% of Western culture lives in this disembodied, disconnected state — busy, productive, and unable to relate.

  • Living in constant sympathetic activation disconnects people from their bodies and relational capacity
  • 75% of Western culture is estimated to live 'left-shifted'
  • Telltale signs: chronic stress, constant busyness, difficulty slowing down or being present, loneliness despite being surrounded by achievement

75% of our western culture lives more left-shifted. And it is the underlying reason for our epidemic of loneliness right now.

Jessica Baum · 09:00
#loneliness#nervous-system#culture
Explainer24:30

Intergenerational Trauma: Why Parents Pass Down Avoidance Without Meaning To

Jessica and Chris discuss how most parents unintentionally pass down avoidant tendencies because they focus on providing resources (money, activities, opportunities) rather than emotional presence — often because they themselves never received emotional attunement from their own parents.

  • Most parents aren't emotionally unavailable out of malice — they're repeating what wasn't modeled for them
  • Parents often focus on tasks and success rather than meeting a child's emotional needs
  • Chris frames it starkly: kids likely would have preferred less money/resources and more emotional availability
  • What kids actually needed wasn't a bigger birthday party or more activities — it was being held through emotional experiences

Most parents are passing down some avoidant tendencies... they probably didn't get it from their parents and that's how this gets passed down intergenerationally.

Jessica Baum · 25:00

It probably wasn't a bigger birthday party. It was for mom or dad to pick them up and hold them.

Chris Williamson · 27:00
#parenting#intergenerational-trauma#emotional-availability
Explainer41:00

What a 'Ventral' State Feels Like (and How to Tell You're Not In One)

Drawing on Stephen Porges's polyvagal theory, Jessica explains the ventral vagal state — the nervous-system state of safety and social connection — and gives concrete markers for recognizing whether you and a partner are in it.

  • The ventral state is the nervous system's state of safety, connection, and social engagement
  • People shift in and out of it constantly, sometimes within nanoseconds
  • Signs you're in it: steady breath, calm, expansive thoughts, eye contact, feeling more awe/beauty in the world
  • Healing deep attachment wounds requires 'adult anchoring' in a ventral state — trauma can't be moved alone, it needs co-regulation

We can't move trauma alone. We actually need co-regulation and adult anchoring to be with what's in the body with us so we can start…

Jessica Baum · 42:00
#polyvagal-theory#nervous-system#explainer
Explainer44:00

Why Anxious and Avoidant Partners Are Drawn to Each Other

Jessica explains the classic anxious-avoidant dynamic: each is drawn to what feels like their own 'lost' qualities in the other, but when both get scared, they need opposite things — the anxious partner needs to move toward connection, the avoidant partner needs space — trapping the pair in a miserable cycle.

  • Anxious partners are drawn to the avoidant's stoicism and groundedness; avoidants are drawn to the anxious partner's liveliness and expressiveness
  • When triggered, an anxious person runs toward connection to avoid abandonment fear; an avoidant person runs toward space to self-regulate
  • Because they need opposite things when activated, the pair gets stuck in repeating, exhausting cycles
  • Chronic activation in this cycle can cause somatic inflammation over time
  • The fix: more reassurance calms an anxious partner over time and helps the nervous system internalize safety

They both actually need the opposite of what the other can provide.

Jessica Baum · 45:00

There are two boats getting ragged around by the sea at the same time.

Chris Williamson · 44:00
#anxious-attachment#avoidant-attachment#relationships
Explainer58:30

Rupture and Repair: Why Conflict Can Deepen Intimacy

Jessica explains the concept of 'rupture and repair,' rooted in infant-caregiver dynamics, and argues that conflict itself isn't the problem in relationships — it's an opportunity to build deeper intimacy when handled with real understanding rather than avoidance or defensiveness.

  • Rupture and repair originates in infancy: a baby's distress (rupture) followed by a caregiver figuring out the need and reconnecting (repair)
  • How well your parents modeled repair predicts how well you handle conflict as an adult
  • Real repair means understanding the other person's internal experience, not just deciding who's 'right'
  • Couples who avoid conflict entirely (never rupturing) don't get to test whether repair is possible, which can be riskier long-term
  • Shame is the main thing that blocks true repair

When we have conflict, it's an opportunity not only to repair on a deep level, but to build deeper intimacy.

Jessica Baum · 59:30
#conflict#repair#relationships#attachment

Story· 2

Story22:30

Jessica's Own Relationship Awakened Her Childhood Fear of Her Father's Addiction

Jessica shares a personal anecdote: she left a relationship with someone who initially met all her emotional needs but later relapsed into substance abuse — triggering the young part of her that remembered growing up with a father who struggled with substance abuse. Even with deep expertise in attachment science, she couldn't prevent the pattern from recurring.

  • Jessica grew up with a father who struggled with substance abuse and wealth instability
  • She attracted a partner who met her needs early on but later relapsed into substance abuse
  • The relapse awakened a young, scared part of her tied to her father's addiction, not just reactions to her partner
  • Even deep knowledge of interpersonal neurobiology didn't prevent her from being drawn into a familiar painful pattern

I had to work really hard to not make it about him and his use and be with the part of me that was really…

Jessica Baum · 23:00

Implicit memory is like water. It will go to the most familiar pattern... and it will awaken: 'Is this safe or is this dangerous?'

Jessica Baum · 23:30
#personal-story#trauma#addiction#attachment
Story67:00

The Friend Who Vanished After Their First-Ever Fight

Jessica shares a personal anecdote about a friendship that never had any conflict for two years — until one fight happened, after which the friend never spoke to her again, illustrating why untested relationships can be fragile and why she now tells people dating is healthier when it includes some conflict.

  • Jessica had a two-year friendship with zero conflict
  • The first fight that arose ended the friendship permanently — no repair attempt occurred
  • Jessica now advises people dating to actively test conflict/rupture-and-repair capacity early rather than avoid it
  • Untested relationships don't reveal whether both people can validate and see each other's side

We ruptured and we couldn't repair... when you're dating someone you need to have a conflict. You need to see if they can validate you.

Jessica Baum · 67:00
#friendship#conflict#personal-story

Q&A· 1

Q&A00:00

What Does 'Safety' Actually Mean in a Relationship?

Chris and Jessica compare definitions of emotional safety. Jessica's is knowing that whatever happens, she has people around her who will show up for her — meaning safety isn't purely internal, it can be built and 'outsourced' through a support system.

  • Jessica's definition: safety = knowing you have people who will support you no matter what, even amid war, crisis, or uncertainty
  • Chris shares a competing definition from a retreat: safety is 'knowing you'll be okay no matter what happens,' not the absence of hard things
  • Safety isn't purely internal — it can be co-created and 'outsourced' through relationships
  • This directly sets up the book's core topic: secure attachment

Safety is just to feel really connected and like a sense of togetherness when you're with people and a feeling of relaxed and openness in…

Jessica Baum · 00:00

You can be unsafe and the people around you can make you safe.

Chris Williamson · 01:30
#safety#attachment#relationships

Tool· 1

Tool69:30

Jessica Baum's Book 'Safe' and the Free Wheel of Attachment Guide

Jessica points listeners to her book 'Safe: An Attachment-Informed Guide to Building More Secure Relationships and Coming Home to Yourself and Others,' plus a free companion resource: a 'wheel of attachment' worksheet and a video interview with her 82-year-old mentor on moving from insecurity to security.

  • Book: 'Safe' by Jessica Baum — attachment-informed guide to secure relationships
  • Free gift for listeners: a guide to the 'wheel of attachment' exercise, new to this book
  • Bonus video: Jessica interviewing her 82-year-old mentor about insecurity-to-security work
  • The wheel of attachment helps map earliest relationship dynamics as a starting point for self-work

Our earliest relationships, how we felt safe in our home, who we felt safe with... getting in touch with all of those things — that's…

Jessica Baum · 69:30
#book-recommendation#resources#attachment

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway63:00

The 'Disconfirming Experience' That Rewires Old Relationship Fears

Jessica introduces the idea of a 'disconfirming experience' — deliberately revisiting an old wound with someone who has the emotional capacity to respond differently than the original wounding figure did, which is what actually shifts a belief system rather than just talking about it.

  • To heal a wound, you must re-experience it and have it 'met' differently than the original experience
  • You need to feel witnessed, accepted, and not alone in re-experiencing shame or fear
  • You only need one or two disconfirming experiences with someone capable of holding you to start shifting deep belief patterns
  • Choosing the right person matters — repeating rupture with someone who lacks capacity only reinforces the original wound

We need to have a disconfirming experience... we only need one or two of them to be like, 'Oh my god, rupture might not be…

Jessica Baum · 63:30
#healing#attachment#psychology