MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Chris Daw QC17 August 2020

Why We Should Close All Prisons & Legalise Drugs - Chris Daw QC - #211

0Frameworks
18Insights

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 2

Myth Buster10:00

Most People in Prison Aren't Violent Criminals

Countering the assumption that prisons are mostly full of dangerous people, Daw cites figures showing the vast majority of the UK prison population is there for non-violent offenses like drugs, fraud, or theft, with only a small fraction being genuinely dangerous.

  • 69% of UK prisoners are in for non-violent crimes (drugs, fraud, theft)
  • Only 31% are in for violent crime, and many of those are low-level assaults
  • Only around 10-15% of the total prison population are seriously violent/dangerous
  • Only about 60 people out of ~80,000 UK prisoners will never be released

99.9% of them, even the most violent ones, even the murderers, will one day come out of prison.

Chris Daw · 10:30
#prison-statistics#criminal-justice#myth-busting
Myth Buster56:00

Portugal Proves Decriminalizing Drugs Doesn't Increase Use

Countering the common fear that legalizing or decriminalizing drugs leads to more drug use, Daw cites Portugal's decriminalization of drug possession, which resulted in falling drug use and improved health outcomes rather than the predicted surge.

  • Portugal decriminalized possession of drugs years ago, treating use as a healthcare issue
  • Drug use fell and health outcomes improved after decriminalization, contrary to fears
  • Daw notes Portugal's model doesn't go far enough for him because criminals still supply the drugs
  • Common counterargument — 'legalizing drugs increases use' — is described as factually false

In any deregulated or heavily regulated or licensed market, what you see is falling levels of drug use.

Chris Daw · 56:00
#portugal#drug-policy#myth-busting

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take24:00

Criminals Don't Fear Prison Because They Don't Expect to Get Caught

Daw argues from 26 years of direct client experience that the deterrent effect of harsh sentencing is a myth — people who commit crimes simply don't believe they'll be caught, so raising sentence length changes nothing about their behavior.

  • None of Daw's clients over 26 years thought 'I'll get caught and do 10 years, but I'll do it anyway'
  • Even life without parole for drug offenses in some US states doesn't stop people dealing
  • Politicians promising to 'get tough' misunderstand what actually deters crime
  • The real driver of crime is broken lives from broken childhoods, not weak sentencing

None of my clients over 26 years went out one day and thought, 'I know I'm going to get caught for this and I'm going…

Chris Daw · 24:00

Deterrence in prison doesn't work because people don't think about getting caught.

Chris Daw · 24:30
#deterrence#hot-take#criminal-justice

Explainer· 7

Explainer06:00

Why Prisons Function as 'Universities of Crime'

Chris Daw explains that British prisons condition people into criminals rather than rehabilitating them. Inmates emerge with no marketable skills, having spent their time surrounded by other criminals, and are then treated as outcasts by society — which pushes them back toward crime.

  • Prisons are described as 'universities of crime' where inmates learn criminal skills, not job skills
  • Treating people like animals in caged conditions makes them behave like animals on release
  • Labeling someone a 'criminal' repeatedly becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy
  • Analogy: sending someone to 'tennis camp' makes them good at tennis; sending them to prison makes them good at crime, nothing else

If you send someone to prison and they hang out with criminals all day and they learn about crime, they're gonna come out and they're…

Chris Daw · 08:00

If you treat someone like an animal, they behave like one.

Chris Daw · 07:00
#prison-reform#criminal-justice#rehabilitation
Explainer08:30

The Care-System-to-Prison Pipeline

Daw highlights a statistic showing how children raised in the state care system are dramatically more likely to end up incarcerated, arguing this represents a failure of state responsibility rather than individual moral failing.

  • People who were in the care system as children are 15 times more likely to end up in prison
  • Many prisoners have serious untreated mental health or psychiatric conditions
  • Daw frames this as society failing to properly care for damaged children, then punishing the result

You're 15 times more likely to go to prison if you were in care as a child.

Chris Daw · 08:30
#prison-reform#care-system#childhood-trauma
Explainer14:00

Norway's Humane Prisons Cut Reoffending to 20%

Daw contrasts the Norwegian prison model — normal housing, kitchens, humane conditions, used sparingly — with the UK/US punitive model, pointing to dramatically different reoffending rates as evidence for what actually reduces crime.

  • In Norway, only ~20% of released prisoners reoffend, and those are mostly the already most violent
  • In the UK, reoffending rates run up to 75%
  • Norway uses prison rarely and makes conditions as normal as possible when it does
  • Daw calls this an 'absolute cast iron statistical fact' across the world: harsher prisons produce more reoffending

The Norway system, where you treat people humanely and you normalize the conditions, works. The American, and to a large extent the British, model doesn't.

Chris Daw · 14:30
#norway#recidivism#prison-reform#international-comparison
Explainer26:00

Luxembourg's Model: No One Under 18 Can Be a 'Criminal'

Daw explains that in Luxembourg, the age of criminal responsibility matches the voting age (18) — children who commit offenses are handled through education, not the criminal justice system, and are never labeled criminals or given a record.

  • In Luxembourg, no one under 18 can be convicted of a crime — same age as voting
  • Children who offend are worked with in an educational environment, not a prison one
  • The UK criminalizes children as young as 10, younger than even Saudi Arabia's threshold
  • Daw argues labeling children 'young offenders' pushes them into a revolving door of adult criminality

You label someone with something, they will be that thing. Young offenders become adult criminals.

Chris Daw · 27:00
#youth-justice#luxembourg#policy
Explainer33:00

Switzerland's Heroin-Assisted Treatment Program

Daw describes visiting a Swiss clinic that treats heroin addiction as a medical condition rather than a crime — providing safe heroin, clean needles, and health testing — and reports the program achieves higher success rates at reducing drug use than criminal justice approaches.

  • Long-term addicts are given medically supervised heroin, clean needles, HIV/hepatitis testing
  • Program staff say compassion, not judgment, is what reduces addicts' drug use over time
  • Success rate in getting people off drugs is described as far better than criminal justice outcomes
  • Criminal justice approaches were reported to leave more people using drugs after going through the system, not fewer

It's only when you show your compassion and kindness and give them proper medical care that they start to feel less like [expletive] about themselves…

Chris Daw · 33:30
#switzerland#drug-policy#harm-reduction
Explainer37:30

How a $1,000 Kilo of Heroin Becomes $100,000 on UK Streets

Daw breaks down the economics of the illegal drug trade, explaining that heroin is cheap to produce but the illegal transport and criminal markup inflate its price roughly 100x by the time it reaches users — profit that state-regulated production could eliminate.

  • A kilo of heroin costs about $1,000 in source countries like Afghanistan/Pakistan
  • By the time it reaches UK streets, it can sell for around $100,000
  • The markup comes from illegal transport, bribery, and layers of criminal profit, not production cost
  • Daw argues state-licensed production could remove this profit motive entirely and cut out organized crime

You could buy a kilo of heroin for about a thousand dollars. By the time that reaches the streets of Britain it's a hundred thousand.

Chris Daw · 38:00
#drug-economics#organized-crime#policy
Explainer64:00

How Swiss Voters Themselves Chose Drug Reform

Daw explains that Switzerland's progressive drug policy wasn't imposed top-down by politicians but voted in directly by citizens via referendum, after public safety concerns about open drug use pushed them to try a different approach.

  • Visible heroin use and related disorder on Swiss streets drove public demand for change
  • Switzerland uses referendums extensively, letting citizens vote directly on policy
  • The public voted to bring in heroin-assisted treatment and consumption rooms
  • Switzerland ultimately gave drug addiction the same disability-rights protections as other disabilities

It was only when the Swiss people decided that their streets were too dangerous that they voted, literally by referendum, to bring in heroin-assisted treatment.

Chris Daw · 64:00
#switzerland#direct-democracy#drug-policy

Story· 6

Story06:00

The Man Who Entered Prison Drug-Free and Left a Heroin Addict

Daw recounts researching his book and encountering a young man who had never taken drugs before going to prison, but came out addicted to heroin — illustrating how easily accessible drugs are inside UK prisons despite the supposed control environment.

  • A young man with zero prior drug history became a heroin addict during his prison sentence
  • Heroin and other drugs are readily available inside prison
  • Used as evidence that prison fails at its stated purpose of reform

I tell the story of a young man who went into prison never taken a drug in his life and came out a heroin addict.

Chris Daw · 06:00
#prison-reform#drugs#case-study
Story12:00

The London Bridge Attack and the Limits of Long Sentences

Daw tells the story of Usman Khan, who served eight full years in high-security prison before being released and killing two people on London Bridge within a year. He uses it to argue that long, punitive incarceration without rehabilitation fails to change people, and highlights that one victim's father publicly rejected calls for even longer sentences.

  • Usman Khan served 8 years in high-security prison before his release
  • Within a year of release he killed two people on London Bridge
  • Victim Jack Merritt's father David publicly said not to use his son's death to justify longer sentences
  • Daw argues 8 years is an opportunity to change someone, wasted by a purely punitive system

Don't use my son's death as an excuse for longer prison sentences, because my son didn't believe that long prison sentences work.

Chris Daw (paraphrasing David Merritt) · 13:00
#case-study#recidivism#prison-reform
Story30:00

Martha Fernbach: Killed by an Unlabeled Bag of MDMA

Daw tells the tragic story of 15-year-old Martha Fernbach, who died after taking MDMA that turned out to be 91% pure — far stronger than she or her friends expected, since illegal drugs come with no labeling or dosage information. He uses it to argue for regulated, labeled drug supply.

  • Martha, 15, had taken MDMA before without issue but received a batch that was 91% pure
  • She had no way of knowing the purity, unlike buying labeled alcohol
  • She died within days of taking the drug
  • Daw compares it to sending a child into a pub with an unlabeled drink that might kill them

It's the equivalent of sending a child into a pub and saying, drink this — and we're not telling you what's in it, and it…

Chris Daw · 31:00
#drug-policy#case-study#regulation
Story48:30

Ten Minutes From Google to Buying an AK-47 on the Dark Web

Daw recounts his own first exploration of the dark web while researching his book, describing how quickly it exposed him to drugs, guns, and even hitmen for sale — and how firearms could be shipped disassembled to avoid customs detection.

  • Within 10 minutes of setting up a VPN, Daw was offered any drug, guns, and hitmen
  • Dealers ship firearms broken into 10-20 pieces to evade customs, with replacement parts if any go missing
  • Bullets are included, and buyers can have a working AK-47 within about 48 hours of ordering
  • Accessing it requires deliberate effort (VPN, specific software) — it's not stumbled upon by accident

Within 10 minutes of setting up a VPN, I'm being offered any drug I could possibly imagine, in any quantity, any purity. I'm being offered…

Chris Daw · 49:00
#dark-web#organized-crime#story
Story58:30

An Alabama Judge Admits the System Is 'Crackers' — Off the Record

Daw recounts interviewing an elected appeals court judge in Alabama who privately admitted the harsh sentencing system was insane, but explained he couldn't reform it because sentencing guidelines are set by politicians, and publicly supporting reform would end his elected career.

  • The judge admitted the extreme US incarceration and violent crime rates were 'crazy'
  • He said he's bound by sentencing guidelines set by elected legislators
  • He said publicly favoring legalizing drugs or reducing sentences would get him voted out within five minutes
  • Judges in the US are elected, unlike appointed judges in the UK, which Daw says entrenches punitive politics

If I came out on television and said I'm in favor of legalizing drugs, reducing the prison population... I'd be out of office in five…

Alabama appeals judge (via Chris Daw) · 60:00
#united-states#judiciary#policy#case-study
Story68:00

A Grieving Family Reconsiders What Would Have Saved Their Son

Daw describes a difficult conversation with the parents of a murdered young man, Michael, who initially wanted his killer to have received a longer sentence — until Daw pointed out the killer had cycled in and out of prison since age 15 and came out more violent each time.

  • Michael's killer had been in and out of prison since age 15 before committing murder in his 20s
  • Parents initially argued the killer should have received more prison time
  • Daw suggested the real failure was that prison made the killer more violent, not less
  • The parents, still grieving, were willing to reflect on that reframing

Is there an argument that whatever happened to him in prison didn't work — and the prison system actually chucked him out onto the streets…

Chris Daw · 70:00
#victims#case-study#prison-reform

Tool· 2

Tool18:00

Using Retina Scans and Ankle Tech Instead of Cell Blocks

For the majority of non-violent offenders, Daw proposes replacing prison entirely with home confinement enforced through modern monitoring technology, letting people keep working and stay connected to family while still serving a sentence.

  • Retina scans, voice recognition, and fingerprint tech could confine people to their homes
  • Offenders could be allowed out to work during the day under restriction
  • Cost is a fraction of the ~£50,000/year it costs to keep someone in prison
  • Probation check-ins could happen daily via video call instead of a monthly in-person visit

It's on average £50,000 a year to keep someone in prison. For a fraction of that you could have the technology to monitor them wherever…

Chris Daw · 18:30
#prison-alternatives#technology#policy
Tool68:00

Chris Daw's Book 'Justice on Trial' and BBC Documentary 'Crime: Are We Tough Enough?'

Chris Daw points listeners to his book 'Justice on Trial' and his five-part BBC One documentary series, which covers prison visits and interviews with prisoners, judges, and victims' families across multiple countries, as further reading/viewing on these topics.

  • Book: 'Justice on Trial', published the day of this interview
  • BBC documentary: 'Crime: Are We Tough Enough?', five episodes, available on BBC iPlayer
  • Daw is also active on Twitter (@crimlawuk) engaging policymakers and MPs on these issues
  • He runs a YouTube channel (Christopher QC) with career guidance for aspiring lawyers from non-traditional backgrounds
#book-recommendation#resources