Why 'sitting is the new smoking' is messier than it sounds
The link between sitting itself and poor health is genuinely hard to prove, because active people simply enjoy better outcomes and confounders like smoking, drinking and social class muddy the data. Coal miners were intensely active yet died young; sedentary CEOs often live long, healthy lives. What's solid is that being physically active lowers cardiovascular and diabetes risk — so tackling inactivity, not sitting in the abstract, is the real priority.
- It's hard to show that sitting as an isolated activity is bad for you
- Active people clearly live longer with less cardiovascular disease and diabetes
- Coal miners were very active but died young; sedentary CEOs often stay healthy
- Confounders like smoking, drinking and social level distort the research
- One academic review still concluded inactivity and sitting cause deaths
“it's harder to prove that just sitting as an activity is actually bad for you”
“it's reasonable to say sitting is killing people”