MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Dr Anna Machin27 July 2024

The Evolutionary Psychology Of Love, Lust & Cheating - Dr Anna Machin - #817

2Frameworks
15Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 3

Myth Buster21:30

Men and women don't experience love differently — it's just heavily gendered

Machin says brain scans of people in love are indistinguishable by sex; there are more differences within the sexes than between them. What varies is genetics, attachment profile and upbringing. A study of children shows five-year-olds all draw the same loving image, but after puberty boys shift to 'big strong man protecting weak woman' — culture, not biology.

  • Machin can't tell a scanned brain's sex from love activations
  • Within-sex variation exceeds between-sex variation
  • Boys are taught to be the protector and hide emotion
  • In cultures without those stories, men are openly emotional about love

if I put somebody in my scanner and nobody tells me what sex they are I would not be able to tell from looking at…

Dr. Anna Machin · 21:30
#gender#myth#neuroscience#culture
Myth Buster48:00

Aromantics and the myth that romantic love sits at the top

Aromantic people experience platonic, familial, community and even religious love but not romantic love, and are often wrongly seen as cold. Machin uses them to argue there is no hierarchy of love with romance at the pinnacle: for health, longevity and life satisfaction, what matters is having loving relationships, not which type.

  • Aromantics feel deep love, just not romantic love; many are also asexual
  • Society treats them as 'weird' for lacking romance
  • Relationships are the biggest factor in mental/physical health and longevity
  • The type of love barely matters for those health benefits

there is no hierarchy, it's flat, and what we need to embrace as humans is how lucky we are to be able to love in…

Dr. Anna Machin · 50:30
#aromantic#myth#health#hierarchy-of-love
Myth Buster87:30

Parasocial love isn't pathological — your brain doesn't understand screens

Machin explains parasocial love — attachment to celebrities or fictional characters — is developmentally useful in teens and, contrary to old assumptions, normal in well-adjusted adults. The brain treats an on-screen person as if they're in the room, and these figures can be genuine, beneficial attachment figures, especially for LGBTQ+ youth lacking local role models.

  • Teen crushes let you explore sexuality and love safely 'in your head'
  • Most adults with parasocial bonds have normal social networks
  • The brain reacts to on-screen people as if physically present
  • Parasocial relationships only emerged with regular TV from the 1950s

your brain doesn't understand screens, when it sees someone on a telly it's like they're in the room with you

Dr. Anna Machin · 90:00
#parasocial#celebrity#myth#attachment

Hot Take· 2

Hot Take44:30

Monogamy is a societal construct — and polyamory is a 'paleo relationship'

Machin argues no species is purely monogamous; monogamy is largely a social construct placed on our biology to keep reproduction predictable and society orderly. Polyamorists, she says, are effectively acknowledging humans' natural tendency toward multiple relationships and running it openly with rules and communication — 'paleo relationships'.

  • Monogamy constrains biology to keep the masses predictable
  • Marriage and legal frameworks formalise that control
  • Polyamory openly acknowledges what many people do covertly
  • Consensual non-monogamy is rising among younger generations

monogamy is to a large part a societal construct that's been placed upon our biological behaviour in a way to try and constrain it

Dr. Anna Machin · 44:30

they've created like paleo relationships... this is actually how most people behave but most people pretend it's not happening

Chris Williamson · 47:00
#monogamy#polyamory#society#relationships
Hot Take74:30

Evolutionary psychology can't explain what love feels like

Williamson argues evolutionary psychology is the most complete vision of human mating we have, yet misses the phenomenological experience — what it feels like to fall in love. Machin agrees: EP gives a good starting set of drivers, but humans are too complex to be fully explained by it. Some of love is unmeasurable, which is why art, poetry and music exist to express it.

  • EP offers drivers to lay over behaviour, not a complete explanation
  • Machin says we may understand only ~10% of what love is doing
  • The subjective, unmeasurable core is why art and literature exist
  • EP is a good place to start but 'not the Bible'

I can explain all of these things to you but that's not the experience of it... EP is a good place to start but it's…

Dr. Anna Machin · 79:00
#evolutionary-psychology#phenomenology#philosophy#art

Explainer· 9

Explainer00:00

Why love evolved: biological bribery to make cooperation bearable

Machin argues love evolved because humans are the most cooperative species but cooperation is costly and stressful. Love is a set of neurochemicals that motivate and reward us for starting and maintaining survival-critical relationships. At its most basic level it is 'biological bribery' that makes a very difficult, dangerous thing feel worthwhile.

  • Humans juggle ~150 relationships that can last decades
  • Being in a group is costly, stressful and sometimes dangerous
  • Love is neurochemistry that rewards keeping survival-critical bonds
  • It makes you sacrifice, stay vigilant, and wake at 3am for the baby

it's kind of like a form of biological bribery... a set of neurochemicals which motivate and reward you for starting and then maintaining what we…

Dr. Anna Machin · 01:00
#evolution#cooperation#neurochemistry#survival
Explainer07:00

Lust, attraction and love are three separate brain systems

Machin separates the systems people usually blur. Lust runs on the hypothalamus and sex hormones and exists only in romantic relationships. Attraction, driven by oxytocin and dopamine, underpins all forms of love including friendship and bonding with a newborn. Long-term love is a further, distinct set of neurochemicals.

  • Lust is hypothalamus-driven and tied to sex hormones
  • Attraction is oxytocin/dopamine and starts every relationship, not just romance
  • Oxytocin orients you to people and quiets the amygdala's fear voices
  • Dopamine adds the motivational kick to actually approach someone

lust and attraction are two entirely separate systems... attraction underpins all forms of love, lust is only there in romantic relationships

Dr. Anna Machin · 07:30
#lust#attraction#oxytocin#dopamine
Explainer11:30

Why women can literally smell genetic compatibility

Some genes in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), which shapes immune diversity, also underpin smell. Machin explains women can unconsciously smell how close a man's MHC genes are to their own; too close smells wrong because it signals inbreeding. The evolutionary payoff is a child with the most diverse possible immune response.

  • MHC genes shape both immune diversity and, oddly, sense of smell
  • Women prefer partners whose MHC is far from their own
  • The 'something I can't put my finger on' feeling may be this
  • Higher stakes of pregnancy may explain why women can do it and men can't

you need your partner to have an MHC complex as far away from yours as possible and so what we find with women is they…

Dr. Anna Machin · 12:00
#genetics#attraction#immune-system#mate-choice
Explainer17:00

Beta-endorphin: the neurochemical that sustains long-term love

Machin explains why oxytocin can't underpin decades-long bonds: it lasts about 30 minutes, you grow tolerant to it, and it mostly flows in reproductive relationships. Beta-endorphin, the body's opiate, is released by non-reproductive social activities like laughter, touch, exercise, dancing and singing, doesn't wear off, and underpins the full human relationship network.

  • Oxytocin is short-lived (~30 min) and you build tolerance
  • Most of our 150 relationships aren't sexual or reproductive
  • Beta-endorphin was first the body's painkiller, then co-opted socially
  • Released by laughter, touch, exercise, dance, singing — even a hot curry

beta-endorphin is the neurochemical of long-term love, it's your body's opiate... and we don't grow tolerant to it over time

Dr. Anna Machin · 18:30
#neurochemistry#long-term-love#bonding#endorphins
Explainer30:30

'Armour-plated genes': why some people survive terrible childhoods intact

Machin describes differentially susceptible genes on the oxytocin receptor gene that determine how strongly your environment shapes your attachment profile. People carrying certain variants are buffered: a neglectful upbringing has far less effect on their later relationships, letting them 'sail through' bad environments unscathed.

  • Environment normally sculpts attachment via early brain growth
  • Some gene variants blunt the environment's power over attachment
  • This protects carriers from neglectful or harsh upbringings
  • The genetics get more complex the deeper researchers dig

we kind of call them the armour plated genes... they are kind of protected from that environment and they can kind of sail through that…

Dr. Anna Machin · 31:30
#genetics#attachment#resilience#epigenetics
Explainer36:00

Why people cheat: reproductive strategy for both sexes

Machin frames infidelity as an evolutionary reproductive strategy. Men can raise reproductive success by spreading genes if a child can be raised without them. Women may seek better genes than their committed partner offers — keeping an investing partner while getting stronger genes elsewhere. Machin leans toward dual-mating over mate-switching but says both occur.

  • Monogamous species commonly have affairs to boost reproductive success
  • Even 'monogamous' gibbons sneak off to mate
  • Women's affairs tend to be with more facially symmetrical (better-genes) men
  • The most symmetrical man isn't the best overall mate — provision matters

from an evolutionary point of view being unfaithful makes perfect sense because ultimately your job... is to maximize your reproductive success

Dr. Anna Machin · 38:30
#cheating#infidelity#dual-mating#reproduction
Explainer58:30

The dark side of love: the only species that uses love to manipulate

Machin says humans are the only creatures that weaponise love, because we need it so viscerally. From 'if you loved me you'd...' to serious coercion and abuse, love's addictiveness (via beta-endorphin) makes it exploitable. She notes love itself evolved as a form of control — evolution's way of making us reproduce and cooperate.

  • Needing love so deeply makes it usable against us
  • Every human adaptation has a downside; love's is manipulation
  • Beta-endorphin's addictiveness makes some people harder to free
  • Jealousy is adaptive in moderation but dangerous at the extreme

the only thing that definitely separates us from the animals is that we are the only creature that uses love to manipulate

Dr. Anna Machin · 59:00
#abuse#coercion#jealousy#dark-side
Explainer66:30

Female friendships are becoming women's survival-critical relationships

Machin's research found women are often more emotionally intimate with their best female friends than with romantic partners. As more women stay single or child-free — enabled by contraception and financial independence — their friendships increasingly become their survival-critical 'chosen family', delivering the same love benefits as romance or parenthood.

  • Women often reserve their deepest vulnerabilities for female friends
  • A quiet revolution over the last 10-20 years in friendship's importance
  • Contraception and independence freed women from marrying for survival
  • Emotional vulnerability is the mechanism that makes these bonds so tight

they are more emotionally intimate with their best female best friends than they are with their romantic partner

Dr. Anna Machin · 67:00
#friendship#women#chosen-family#intimacy
Explainer90:30

Religious love shows the same neural fingerprint as human love

Machin describes scanning religious followers, such as nuns, during mystical experiences with God: the brain shows the fingerprint of love, plus activity in the region that fires when communing with another sentient being. She found nuns have fully reciprocal attachment relationships with God, and that personal (conversational) prayer confers measurable health and longevity benefits.

  • Mystical experiences light up the same love signature on a scanner
  • Believers report reciprocity, empathy and maintenance behaviours with God
  • Religious love is likely the same mechanism behind parasocial love
  • Personal prayer, not just churchgoing, drives the health benefits

absolutely on that screen is the fingerprint of love... they are in love with a sentient being who is real

Dr. Anna Machin · 91:30
#religion#neuroscience#prayer#attachment

Story· 1

Story60:30

What male victims of domestic abuse say about love

Machin has studied male victims of domestic violence. Many stay for love — believing they can rescue or change a damaged partner, or describing love as literally blind and being stunned in hindsight at what they didn't see. Others stay for love of their children, fearing a UK court system biased toward mothers in custody.

  • Victims often believe their love can rescue or change the abuser
  • 'Love is blind' is neurologically real — part of the mentalizing brain shuts down
  • One man watched his wife abuse her own parents and normalised it
  • Fear of losing custody keeps some fathers in abusive homes

they will talk about love being blind... they're just so overwhelmed by it that they don't see this thing in front of them

Dr. Anna Machin · 62:30
#domestic-abuse#male-victims#love-is-blind#custody