MModern Wisdom
← All episodes
Dr Leah Lagos24 August 2024

How To Improve Your Heart Rate Variability - Dr Leah Lagos - #829

3Frameworks
11Insights

Listen

Frameworks in this episode

Insights & moments

The myth-busts, hot takes, explainers, and tools worth keeping.

Myth Buster· 1

Myth Buster35:00

Nasal breathing hype vs what actually raises HRV

Contrary to the popular nasal-breathing trend, Lagos's testing shows that for most people inhaling through the nose but exhaling through the mouth raises HRV more than pure nasal breathing. The nose-in, mouth-out pattern increases peak expiratory flow, which her endurance athletes credit with reduced fatigue by around week seven. She still defers to individuals who feel better another way.

  • Pure nasal breathing rarely beat nose-in, mouth-out in her measurements
  • Nose-in, mouth-out increases peak expiratory flow and cardiovascular effects
  • Endurance athletes report less fatigue by about week seven
  • There is no one-size-fits-all; she honors what feels right for each person

there is something about the inhaling through the nose and the exhaling through the mouth that increases what's called peak expiratory flow

Dr. Leah Lagos · 37:00
#nasal-breathing#breathwork#myth#endurance

Hot Take· 1

Hot Take06:00

Why 'just let it go' fails and the body-up fix that works

As a psychologist, Lagos argues that telling a stressed person to let go, calm down or think differently often makes them more stressed. Letting go is better understood as a physiological skill taught through HRV biofeedback. You go bottom-up, teaching the autonomic nervous system to release first, rather than top-down from the mind.

  • Letting go is largely a physiological construct, not a cognitive one
  • Cognitive techniques alone are weaker than training the nervous system
  • Bottom-up (body to mind) beats top-down (mind commanding calm)
  • Telling someone to calm down often increases their stress

letting go is much more a physiological construct that can be taught through processes such as heart rate variability biofeedback training than just cognitive techniques

Dr. Leah Lagos · 06:30
#psychology#stress#biofeedback#mindset

Explainer· 5

Explainer01:00

What HRV really is, explained without the science overwhelm

Lagos reframes heart rate variability away from the intimidating clinical definition toward resonant sinus arrhythmia (RSA): when you inhale your heart rate rises and when you exhale it falls. The goal is to make those oscillations as big and beautiful as possible, like ocean waves. Historically HRV originated in maternity wards to predict a baby's vitality before shifting to cardiovascular and clinical use.

  • HRV is the variability in the time between heartbeats, measured in milliseconds
  • Bigger oscillations signal greater health, resilience and adaptability
  • RSA is the easier lens: heart rate up on inhale, down on exhale
  • The metric originated in obstetrics to predict newborn vitality

we want that variation to be as big and beautiful as possible almost like ocean-like waves

Dr. Leah Lagos · 02:00
#hrv#rsa#physiology#explainer
Explainer03:30

Why HRV drops under stress: the reptilian energy-conservation theory

Chris asks what adaptive advantage a lower HRV under stress could give. Lagos's hypothesis ties it to a reptilian immobilization response that conserves energy and tries to keep the body safe. In a dynamic modern world this backfires: with reduced flexibility we ruminate and extend the stressor far longer than needed.

  • Low HRV under stress may stem from a reptilian immobilization response
  • The autonomic nervous system fragments what Lagos calls autonomic bandwidth to conserve energy
  • In modern life this keeps us stuck and prolongs the stressor through rumination
  • The response usually lasts longer than it is useful

we ruminate on the stressor for so long that we actually extend the stressor for a good amount of time

Dr. Leah Lagos · 05:30
#stress#evolution#autonomic-nervous-system#hrv
Explainer06:30

What determines your personal HRV range

HRV range varies widely between people for biological, medical and lifestyle reasons. Low HRV can flag a clinical condition, chronic unmanaged stress, or simply high sensitivity. Lagos describes 'biologically gifted' people who feel deeply and whose heart rate may jump 30 beats under stress where another jumps 10, though they can sharpen their response through stronger baroreflex gain.

  • Range is shaped by biology, medical conditions and external factors
  • Low HRV can indicate a clinical condition worth investigating
  • Highly sensitive 'biologically gifted' people react more strongly, not consciously
  • Sleep, alcohol, lack of exercise and chronic stress all dampen HRV
  • Comparing your HRV to others (e.g. athletes in the 200s) is pointless

in stressful moments their heart rate reactivity may jump 30 beats whereas someone else may jump 10

Dr. Leah Lagos · 08:00
#hrv#individual-differences#sensitivity#baroreflex
Explainer11:00

HRV, cognitive dexterity and inhibition in the prefrontal cortex

Beyond autonomic resilience, recent research links HRV to what Lagos calls cognitive dexterity: the ability to dive deeply into a subject then zoom out, or to pause before reacting. The first cognitive skill she trains is inhibition, screening out negative thoughts and considering the desired behavior before acting, a process HRV impacts through the prefrontal lobes.

  • HRV correlates with cognitive dexterity, the mind's ability to oscillate
  • Cognitive dexterity means switching between deep focus and contextual zoom-out
  • Inhibition, pausing before reacting, is the first cognitive skill Lagos trains
  • The effect runs through the prefrontal lobes

the ability to oscillate is what I call cognitive dexterity

Dr. Leah Lagos · 12:30
#cognition#prefrontal-cortex#inhibition#focus
Explainer14:30

HRV, heart health and longevity

Healthier hearts do tend to have higher HRV; low HRV correlates with cardiovascular conditions while abundant oscillations are associated with longevity. In Lagos's 12-week clinic training, many clients see resting heart rate drop about five beats independent of physical activity, for example from 65 to 60, reflecting improved cardiovascular efficiency.

  • Low HRV is correlated with cardiovascular conditions
  • Larger oscillations are associated with a longer life
  • First 12 weeks often drop resting heart rate ~5 beats independent of exercise
  • Clients often stay for years, calling it a change of life not just a change of heart

in the first 12 weeks we often see the heart rate independent of physical activity drop five beats

Dr. Leah Lagos · 15:30
#heart-health#longevity#resting-heart-rate#hrv

Story· 1

Story41:30

The surprising things that moved clients' HRV

Lagos shares unexpected interventions she measured against HRV: acupuncture improved it, two actors arriving straight from energy-healing sessions showed higher in-the-moment readings (without a baseline change), sound baths activated the parasympathetic system, the Lyma supplement improved both HRV and sleep, and light exposure via a Verilux lamp raised HRV. Her point: use HRV as an objective metric to test whether any intervention actually works for you.

  • Acupuncture improved HRV for some clients
  • Energy healing raised in-the-moment HRV but not baseline
  • Sound baths activated the parasympathetic nervous system
  • The Lyma supplement improved HRV and sleep in clients she measured
  • Light exposure (Verilux lamp) also moved HRV
  • HRV is a reliable metric to test any intervention's effect

use HRV as a metric to determine the effectiveness of an intervention

Dr. Leah Lagos · 44:00
#interventions#supplements#light-exposure#acupuncture

Q&A· 1

Q&A39:00

VO2 max training vs resonant breathing for HRV

Chris asks whether raising fitness via VO2 max or doing resonant breathing matters more for HRV. Lagos says they work beautifully together and neither is strictly better, but breathing training does something fitness does not: it develops an unconscious reflex that kicks in on its own to modulate stress. She avoids prescribing specific physical protocols, though she has seen certain running or swimming distances reliably boost individual HRV.

  • Fitness and resonant breathing complement each other, not compete
  • Breathing builds an automatic stress-modulating reflex that VO2 max does not
  • Lagos does not prescribe zone 2 vs high-intensity herself
  • Specific individualized distances (running, swimming) can reliably raise HRV

what the HRV does the VO2 max does not is developing a reflex that kicks in on its own unconsciously to help you modulate stress

Dr. Leah Lagos · 39:30
#vo2-max#fitness#training#hrv

Tool· 1

Tool44:30

How to measure HRV without fooling yourself

Lagos explains the reliable ways to measure HRV and the common pitfalls. Nocturnal HRV is fairly reliable due to less movement, but drinking, late eating, restless nights, bathroom trips or even foot twitches skew readings. She rates the Oura ring, Elite HRV and Polar sensors, favoring Polar for its scientific reliability and in-the-moment plus overnight capture. Abnormal numbers usually mean a behavior or a sensor issue, not cause for panic.

  • Nocturnal HRV is fairly reliable; less movement, fewer variables
  • Alcohol, late meals, restless sleep and movement all skew readings
  • Oura, Elite HRV and Polar are her go-to devices
  • Polar has high scientific reliability and captures both in-the-moment and sleep
  • All data is good data; aberrations point to behavior or the wearable

nocturnal HRV is a fairly reliable way to measure heart rate variability because there's generally less movement at night

Dr. Leah Lagos · 44:30
#wearables#measurement#oura#polar

Takeaway· 1

Takeaway50:30

Non-responders, PTSD and the safety-imprint fix

Non-responders to resonant breathing usually have an underlying cause: paralyzing chronic stress, lack of recovery, or overtraining, which once addressed lets training work across ages worldwide. PTSD can interfere with immediate effects because the body is in a startle state, but persistence pays off. For stuck clients, Lagos pairs the breathing with the felt memory of a moment of safety, love or connection, such as holding a child for the first time, on the inhale.

  • True non-responders are rare; the block is usually chronic stress, poor recovery or overtraining
  • PTSD slows the immediate effect but the biofeedback still works with persistence
  • Pair the breath with the feeling, not the thought, of a safe memory
  • Reconnect to a safety imprint on the inhale and release the rest on the exhale

connecting to a time in your life you felt really safe connected or a sense of love and letting go of trying so hard

Dr. Leah Lagos · 54:30
#ptsd#trauma#safety#resilience